Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Did Herschel see Uranus' ring in 1789????

Started by yahganlang, 04/23/2007 02:45AM
Posted 04/23/2007 02:45AM Opening Post
See http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/6569849.stm

If true this is very neat indeed. With industrial and light pollution, its amazing that we can see our little toes these days, let alone the sky.

Jess Tauber
Posted 04/23/2007 10:30AM #1
Hello:

I find the article to be highly dubious. I have observed Uranus several times, and I haven't seen the rings but have seen three of its moons. The moons are REALLY faint in a 16", but are very bright compared to the rings and farther away. The idea that colder temperatures freezing out water vapor and thus making it easier to see the ring is total nonsense. If that's the case, someone should have seen the rings a long time ago since there is no shortage of cold observing sites. The air over Mauna Kea is very clean, dry, and dark, but we don't see the rings from here.

The only time I've taken an image of the rings is with adaptive optics on a 3m telescope in the infrared! The article mentions Keck observatios that the rings have a red color. They are probably refering to the Keck AO image of Uranus, which was taken in the infrared! In the infrared tri-color image, Uranus looks aqua blue in the infrared for the same reason it looks aqua blue in the visible: methane absorption. The rings glow in the infrared due to thier thermal emission, so they're brightest at K-band (2.2 microns), which is used as the red channel.

The darkening of the rings of Saturn observed by Cassini is very slight, not the huge change in albedo that would be required to make the rings of Uranus visible. It also doesn't make sense that the rings of Saturn should be visible for much more than 400 years (the effect of the rings on Saturn's total brightness has been known since antiquity), but the visibility of the rings of Uranus comes and goes. I don't think the changing brightness argument holds water.

Given that it's hard for HST and large ground based scopes to observe the rings of Uranus, and that no one since has visually observed the rings, makes me very suspicious of the observations. I can't offer an explaination as to what he did observe, but I don't think it was the rings.

Cheers
Mike Connelley