Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Mars to be its brightest on 8/27!!

Started by cdculbertson, 08/16/2007 10:37PM
Posted 08/16/2007 10:37PM Opening Post
8)

Is anyone else getting really tired of debunking this tired email?

Hard to believe that two oppositions later, this thing is still making the rounds. The thing is, those friends and coworkers that come to tell me about this are really excited to "inform" me about the event, and they always walk away disappointed at hearing the truth. BTW, where did the whole thing about "two full moons" come from anyway? Mars was bright in '03, but not that bright! :S

Doug
Midway, FL
Posted 08/16/2007 11:21PM | Edited 08/16/2007 11:22PM #1
It all came from a very good article that showed and stated that 'if you keep one eye to a telescope and look at Mars at about 100 power, and use your other eye unaided to view the full moon (at the same time), then mars in the telescope will appear the same size as the full moon. Of course the wording that was "cut out" of the original article left the very important critical information on the next line sitting behind.

I read the original article.

edz
Posted 08/17/2007 02:19AM | Edited 08/17/2007 12:59PM #2
Doug Culbertson said:

8)

Is anyone else getting really tired of debunking this tired email?

Hard to believe that two oppositions later, this thing is still making the rounds. The thing is, those friends and coworkers that come to tell me about this are really excited to "inform" me about the event, and they always walk away disappointed at hearing the truth. BTW, where did the whole thing about "two full moons" come from anyway? Mars was bright in '03, but not that bright! :S

Doug
Midway, FL

Ditto that Doug! I've had 5 or 6 people at work ask me about this. One of my less liked co-workers (big-time jerk) showed me the email, and when I told him that it's a hoax, he got this perplexed look on his face and indignantly asked, "how do you know?". Since we get to work before sunrise, I took him outside, showed him Mars, and said, "Take a good look. If, in two weeks, that little speck of light looks as big as the full moon to the naked eye, we are indeed in big trouble".

Rex


Oklahoma State University--The University of Oklahoma!--GO POKES!! GO STATE!!
Posted 08/17/2007 05:39AM #3
You mean it isn't going to happen?

Shoots my plans.

Alex
Posted 08/18/2007 12:32PM | Edited 08/18/2007 12:35PM #4
Hi Doug and all,

No kidding. I was out last night at my favorite dark sky site. While setting my scope up a carload of people pulled in down from me and got out chairs to get ready for the show. A couple of the ladies came by for a walk and I showed them Jupiter. Got a bunch of Wows from them and the rest of the folks came over. One of the Dads remarked how great I'll be able to see Mars in it and proceeded to tell me how mars would be as big as the full Moon. I politely told him that it was an urban legend and if they wanted to see Mars they would have to wait awhile, but that it would be pretty small even in the telescope. I did give them a naked eye tour of the evening sky and they least stayed long enough to show thier kids the Milky Way and see a few left over Perseids. grin
Posted 08/18/2007 03:27PM #5
The 2003 Moon/Mars article gets recirculated every August because the author neglected to mention the year. Then one of those who passed it along left out mention of the need for a 75 power telescope for Mars to appear as large as a Full Moon. The entire episode reminds me of the children's telephone game in which a story mutates with each retelling. The lesson to be learned is to not believe mass e-mailings without confirmation. This particular example is relatively harmless, but that may not always be the case. More importantly, do not forward e-mails to friends before thoroughly checking them out. Your reputation could be in jeopardy. wink

For astronomical graphics, including
monthly wallpaper calendar, visit:
CurtRenz.com/astronomical

Curt Renz
Posted 08/29/2007 12:58AM #6
That is funny !
It did happen last year and this moring as I was showing my neighbor the eclipse and she brought up mars ! Knew nothing about the eclipse, but new this was mars greatest !! lol