Canon 20Da vs 20D Noise: Measurement

Started by jhapeman, 10/18/2005 03:22AM
Posted 10/18/2005 03:22AM Opening Post
OK, so there has been something done here to reduce the noise. The Sky & Telescope review mentioned the lower noise of the 20Da. I decided to check it myself, and like Alan Dyer, I used Noise Ninja to measure the noise. I fully sampled each image to get a good averaged noise measurement. I have also attached a photo that shows exposures from each camera. Please note that appearance alone is not enough to judge the noise; the images are reduced so much that you can't see the noise on the lower ISO images, but it was there.

Parameters: Both cameras set in the same dark room, no lens (just the body cap), 10-minute exposures. Images were shot in RAW, converted in Photoshop CS2 with the same settings--pushed 4 stops to exaggerate the noise--and then reduced and converted to jpegs. I turned off the Long Exposure Noise Reduction function on both cameras in order to measure the *native* noise of the camera.

Here is what we get for the 20Da:

ISO 3200, Noise 384, 161 Luminance, 223 Chroma
ISO 1600, Noise 287, 123 Luminance, 164 Chroma
ISO 800, Noise 71, 28 Luminance, 43 Chroma
ISO 400, Noise 13, 7 Luminance, 6 Chroma
ISO 200, Noise 3, 2 Luminance, 1 Chroma
ISO 100, Noise 1, 1 Luminance, 0 Chroma

And now the 20D "Classic":

ISO 3200, Noise 625, 285 Luminance, 340 Chroma
ISO 1600, Noise 310, 134 Luminance, 176 Chroma
ISO 800, Noise 151, 66 Luminance, 86 Chroma
ISO 400, Noise 99, 44 Luminance, 54 Chroma
ISO 200, Noise 33, 16 Luminance, 16 Chroma
ISO 100, Noise 20, 11 Luminance, 9 Chroma

Anyway you look at it, the 20Da has a lot less noise. The picture shows it nicely. The one confusing image is the ISO3200 image; here the 20Da looks brighter, but its not noise--at full size you can see it's very fine-grained. I suspect it is leaked IR that makes the image look bright. The Noise Ninja measurements show the real noise.

Anyway, to me the 20Da continues to be a champ: Lower noise, much-increased red sensitivity, yet still useful for regular day-to-day imaging. When you include the live focusing mode, included AC adapter, etc, the price seems much more reasonable. I can't wait for new moon at our house up north, with dark skies, so I can really give this thing a workout for some wide-field milky way imaging before the summer milky way is gone for the year.

Jeff

Attached Image:

jhapeman's attachment for post 27536

Jeff 8O
Posted 10/18/2005 04:14AM #1
Very interesting comparison Jeff. Thanks for taking the trouble. DSLR's continue to improve and no doubt will take over from cooled CCDs. Cooled CCDs still have some advantages but sometimes its hard to see that unless it is a dim target.

DSLR's are way easier to use and way easier to process the images than cooled CCDs which seem fussy and clumsy with all the cables..

Greg.
Posted 10/18/2005 03:48PM #2
Thanks for this very enlightening comparison Jeff...
Things are definitely improving as DSLRs are evolving...

I can certainly see a very bright future for the DSLRs and Astrophotography...


Clear skies, and thanks for sharing! 8)

Ivan Gastaldo 8)
Coconut Creek, FL

Ivan's Observatory
Lat 26N 16' 48" Long 80W 10' 48"
[COLOR="Red"]Personal Website:[/COLOR] http://www.ivangastaldo.com

CCD Imaging and Processing/Deep Sky - Moderator
I like to complain about everything - Moderator