Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Last glimpse of (wild) ducks.

Started by hakescl, 11/17/2008 09:57PM
Posted 11/17/2008 09:57PM Opening Post
I have been trying different scaling options, so removed the "standard" 6.3 focal reducer for this one. I wanted an open cluster to verify the scale with different filters, and M11 is one of my favorite visual objects. (Didn't realize it was already so low!) RGB totals here are 9, 9, and 11 minutes all in 1 minute subs, (trying to not saturate anywhere). This puts the pixel scale factor at ~.71".

I tried cleaning up the noise, but on my first cut lost many of the really dim stars, so this version is less processed than it could be. So what do you think - should I smooth and sharpen more? I also have some L data that could be added, but my experience is that would wash out the colors.

Charlie

Attached Image:

hakescl's attachment for post 44630

Fort Lewis Observatory: (37.238, -108.052) ~2360m (7744 ft.) elevation.
Darkness - typically 6.5+
Scope - Meade 16" LX200; f6.3 focal reducer
Focus - JMI Smart focus
Camera - SBIG ST-10XE; (~.5"/pixel)
Guiding - AO-8 and/or Meade 5"/DSI/PHD
http://www.fortlewis.edu/observatory
Posted 11/20/2008 12:43PM #1
Charles, I believe you hit the spot... further processing/smoothing might get rid of data. Your image looks pretty good as it is. 8)

Ivan Gastaldo 8)
Coconut Creek, FL

Ivan's Observatory
Lat 26N 16' 48" Long 80W 10' 48"
[COLOR="Red"]Personal Website:[/COLOR] http://www.ivangastaldo.com

CCD Imaging and Processing/Deep Sky - Moderator
I like to complain about everything - Moderator
Posted 11/21/2008 05:13PM | Edited 11/21/2008 05:15PM #2
Hi Charles,

I believe that your main problem here is not processing, but focus and guiding or lack of it. In my opinion the focus is a bit on the soft side.
Was your seeing really bad? 'Cause this would explain the difficulty in getting a good focus.
Were your subs unguided? I assume they must have been given the short duration.
If that is the case, and you were shooting at F10 with a good polar alignment, I believe that you should consider one of the 2 options:
(a) reduce the exposure time (not adviced since 1min is already quite short);
(b) start guiding your exposures (much better).
In fact your stars are a bit oblongated, but with a focal length of more than 4000mm (your 16" at F10) shooting unguided it is to be expected even with a SUPER mount wink

Ciao Charles

Luca

www.amun-ra.org
Solar Imaging Website
Posted 11/21/2008 09:38PM #3
I would recommend checking your focus every 15 minutes if the temperature is falling. Shorten your exposure time until the stars are round. For this bright object and for the 16" aperture, you should have plenty of light to register stars. For best resolution you would reduce the exposure time and increase the number of frames that you want to stack.

The oval stars may not be due to tracking, but could indeed be due to tube currents. You can verify that by changing the focus point and noting the shape and direction of the ovality. At some sweet spot the focus will be best and the stars will be round.

Even if the stars are somewhat oval, you can fix a small amount of ovality in photoshop by stacking a copy of each frame and using the Darken mode to make the stars round (see attached image). It will not fix coma issues, but will fix small amounts of ovality.

Rolando

Attached Image:

RolandC's attachment for post 126448