Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Opinions. the best 100mm APO for imaging?

Started by fblue, 10/31/2008 06:04PM
Posted 10/31/2008 06:04PM Opening Post
Just curious what the opinions are on this. I would like to get a faster APO that is more adept at imaging than the TV-102, which makes a great visual scope.
I am interesting in what and why. If I am going to make a change, then I would like it to be the best option. grin

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 10/31/2008 06:10PM #1
With a largish chip probably the NP-101. The Tak TSA is an astounding 102mm scope at F/8 and does equally as well at F/5.9. Also the TMB/APM offerrings are excellent as well.
Posted 10/31/2008 06:30PM #2
You won't break out of the pack until you get something larger than 4". However, if you want to stay with 4", investigate the NP101 or the Tak FSQ. Here's an example of what the NP101 can do with a big chip: http://www.astrophoto.com/M45WF.htm
You can hardly recognize the Pleiades any more in this image.

If you're looking for max resolution and you don't have the best of skies, then a 6" Apo will do a superb job. A 4" will never approach it in terms of resolution.

If you have superior skies (say down at sea level in Florida), then you can go for a 12" aperture to ring out the highest detail in tiny structures (like planetary nebulae and galaxies).

For each situation there is an ideal instrument, 3" - 4" being just a bit on the small side. Yes, you can do a nice job with these small apertures, but you will always be behind the curve.

What can you do with a 6", 7" or even 8" refractor under ideal conditions? Well, I've seen several examples of M33 on this group lately, and they look nice and represent that galaxy well. However, Tony Hallas just sent me a preliminary shot taken with his 8" refractor that is totally mindblowing. He has the proper conditions to take advantage of both the resolution and the purity of the image (lack of scattered light and very high contrast) that a refractive optical system can deliver. In his shot, the spiral arms are resolved into tens of thousands of individual stars. They extend outward far beyond what I have ever seen, and in fact if the image is stretched a bit, the galaxy begins to take on the shape of a giant oval instead of the spider leg pinwheel that we all know so well. The background is peppered full of tiny faint galaxies, and he actually had to crop the image to highlight M33 better. Otherwise it looks lost amid a sandstorm of miniature galaxies. I will post his finished product as soon as he sends me the final version (he is extremely picky about what he wants to show).

As far as what is the ultimate, there is no ultimate. The best that you can do is to match your local conditions, your pocket book and what you want to image, put it all in a blender and hit puree.

Rolando
Posted 10/31/2008 09:38PM | Edited 10/31/2008 09:40PM #3
FSQ106EDX. Its native F5. You can get a reducer for it that takes it to F3.64,

http://www.pbase.com/gregbradley/image/93945265 (not a mosaic, STL11 FSQ106EDX with reducer).

Awesome machine, incredibly well built. No other refractor I know of goes to F3.64.

NP101 seems a great scope.Similar design to the FSQ.

Which was first on the market the NP101 or the FSQ?

Greg.
Posted 10/31/2008 09:51PM | Edited 10/31/2008 09:58PM #4
I'd verify this.

My experience is an STL sized camera needs a 4 inch focuser or you are going to have a hell of a time with vignetting. 2.7 inch focusers are simply too small for the large chip cameras.

Also a reducer will not give you a flat field unless you have the specialised AstroPhysics reducers. So F6 on a TSA is misleading as it will not be a flat field and you will get coma on anything larger than a DSLR and perhaps even a DSLR. Hence it is useless unless using a "small" chipped camera.

So if you intend imaging with a DSLR or smaller chipped camera then this is a viable choice (I would still examine F6 TSA images very carefully for coma even with DSLRs).

I have had an FS152 and it could not handle the STL chip without the 4 inch focuser and flattener. No/doublet/triplet APO can. So its a choice of scopes with 3.5 inches of focuser or more with a dedicated flattener.Add in F5 as a requirement and you've now got only 2 or 3 scopes!!

Hence the popularity of the FSQ or NP101 Petsval design which gives falt field without vignetting 50mm or greater (FSQ is 60mm or more I believe).

As CCD chips become larger the stress on the optics and especially flat fields is becoming harder. Very few scopes really can handle it. Your choices are more limited than you realise: AP, TEC, some Tak, some TMB. Basically anyone who offers a 4 inch focuser and a matching flattener. Now you wanted fast scopes. That limits it even further.

AP traveller with flattener?, Tak FSQ F5, NP101 F5 eehh rrr uhmm I am running out of scopes here!

If you stay with an imaging chip no bigger than a DSLR your choices are much wider.

Given what you've asked I'd say your choice is either Tak FSQ or TV NP101. Perhaps another is the Pentax range.
FSQ would be the better choice with its reducer cost not considered.

Reducers on APOs are essentially useless these days unless you have the AP TCC or are content to never go above DSLR sized cameras.

Greg.