sbig 10xme versus STL 11000 M

Started by stcol99, 03/05/2010 03:12AM
Posted 03/05/2010 03:12AM Opening Post
Does anybody have recommendations concerning the SBIG 10xme versus the STL 11000? It seems that they are almost the same cost when you consider that the 10xme with filter wheel is close to $5700 while the STL-11000 is now on sale for $6000 (or $5,995).

Yet the STL 1000 has a much bigger chip and other benefits. So why is the cost so similar? In addition, I see that there are a lot of expert 10xme users out there, taking very fine photos, and obviously very knowledgeable and skilled at their art.

So I am definitely missing something -- why the strong demand for the 10xme? Why not a huge preference for the STL 11000?
Posted 03/05/2010 04:27AM #1
The high QE of the ST-10 vs the "low" QE of the 11000M is probably a factor. That, plus the large chip on the 11000 might require a field flattener in the imaging train that would not be needed when using the ST-10.


Regards,
Louis Marchesi
[COLOR="Gray"]New London Township, PA[/COLOR]
Posted 03/05/2010 04:38AM #2
The ST10 has high HA sensitivity compared to the ST11000, so narrow band imaging is better with it. It is much more sensitive overall too.

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 03/05/2010 10:22AM | Edited 03/05/2010 02:17PM #3
Let's not forget that one camera is antiblooming while the other (ST10xme) isn't: Big difference in acquiring and processing data!
If you do not calibrate your exposure time wisely in order to avoid large blooms, these may indeed "hide" some data and, while you can remove the blooms easily via software, there is no way to retrieve the data that was behind them!

Cheers
Luca

www.amun-ra.org
Solar Imaging Website