Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Sold the TV102, now what scope do I buy?

Started by fblue, 11/06/2008 12:17AM
Posted 11/06/2008 12:17AM Opening Post
First off, the NP101, I have two available for $2400 & $2500. Both are in excellent condition with Feathertouch focusers and accessories.
These are Petzval scopes, F/5.4 and flat field, wide field scopes that would be ideal for imaging.
Then there is the WO FLT98, a triplet f/6.3 and I have a TV .8 reducer that would work fine with it, giving me f/5.04, wide field, flat field imaging.
Then there is the Astro-Tech 8" RC, f/9 $3000, Feathertouch, narrow field, sub arc sec imaging.
So many choices and not a clue which to buy! :^( What would you buy?
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 11/06/2008 01:17AM #1
Have you looked into one of these?

http://www.astronomics.com/main/product.asp/catalog_name/Astronomics/category_name/U5QNWB3RKWWL8N3EL99F9DX9A0/product_id/AT8RC

-JW:
Posted 11/06/2008 05:01AM #2
Hi Floyd,

Before I made any decision about what scope to purchase I would ask myself what exactly I intended to shoot with it wink

You have a fine widefield scope with your 80mm William optics with it's excellent LOMO lense,If it were me I would not replace it with the 98mm.

I have also heard of the focuser issue with the NP101 though I have never used one so can't say much more about that.I have however seen some great images taken with the NP101,you may want to look at Bernhard Hubles websight http://astrophoton.com/. He has used an NP101 and ST2000xm with great success.Should give you an idea of what can be done with the combo.

If you are looking for more aperture how about something like a 8"f5 newt. A decent G11 could probably handle it pretty well.It would give you a good mix of focal length and aperture and with the ST2000 put you right at 1.5 arc seconds per pixel.This would be great for many,many objects.

Another option would be to sell the 80mm as well and go for a 5" apo,something like a TOA 130 or TMB130 or.. insert your favorite here.These would also be a nice match for the ST2000.

Just my take on it,


Jason

Posted 11/06/2008 12:23PM #3
The Astro-Tech sounds like an expensive gamble. I would wait until the reviews come out first and see what kind of pictures that thing takes. Imaging at 2000 focal length is not the easiest thing to do. The NP-101 is a proven performer. I had one for a short time and never noticed any focus problems. I would go that route if I wanted a 4" scope.

If I was you, I would sell every thing that I own and just buy the first AP-130 F/6 that shows up on Astromart and you will be done buying scopes. That is what I ended up doing. Just keep your mount, your camera, and a cross hair eyepiece. Sell everything else and put your money on a 5" refractor. The TV .8 reducer works perfect with it as long as you don't have a full size chip.
Ralph
Posted 11/06/2008 04:00PM #4
>>Then there is the Astro-Tech 8" RC, f/9 $3000, Feathertouch, narrow field, sub arc sec imaging.>>

I can't even do sub-arc second imagign with my 12" Mak. Sub-arc sec imaging is unrealistic for deep sky astrophotography. Even people with 20"+ scopes do not achieve better than 1.5 arc sec except in rare instances.

Besides, the mount is the most important thing for long exposure deep sky, and it isn't just the tracking accuracy. When imaging with focal lengths above 1500mm, the dynamics of the mount become very important - how well it follows tiny commands on both axes at the arc second level will determine the overall resolution that you get in a 10 - 20 minute subexposure.

Rolando
Posted 11/06/2008 06:10PM | Edited 11/06/2008 09:05PM #5
Hi Floyd,

As others have said, you'll want to consider what you want to shoot.

An NP-101 (or Takahashi FSQ-106) is a terriifc widefield astrograph, but galaxies are going to be tiny.

The Astro-Tech RC will give potentially terrific close-up views of galaxies and planetaries but will be woefully insufficient for widefield vistas.

I personally think you'll need one of each, but that's me wink I've got widefield covered, I'm still trying out all sorts of long-focal-length scopes. Some day I'll get that right.

If as someone said the FOV of the TV-102 is too narrow for you, the Astro-Tech will be like watching a baseball game through a drinking straw!

So, which is it: long focal length (and narrow FOV), or widefield? Or both? grin (I say both, but that's me) wink

HTH,
Eric