Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

the wale SXV H16 vs SXV M25C

Started by stargazer_7000, 04/21/2007 05:31PM
Posted 04/21/2007 05:31PM Opening Post
hi people,

2 extraordinary good nights opened the oportunity to once more compare monochrom CCD and M25Color.

I think You all will be surprised ... abit.

seeing was 8/10 and transp also.
it was great fun to handle the equipment under such almost perfect conditions.
I had a great time ...(-:

first of all let me introduce my final result:

ngc4631
9" TMB Apo f/7 (0,8TeleVue reducer)
SXV M25Color
3 hours (10, 15 minutes subframes)
AstroArt4 (image acqu. autoguiding and preprocessing)
PS CS2, PixInsight LE postprocessing.
seeing and trans 8/10

a small preview:
http://tinyurl.com/2jj25t

1500x:
http://tinyurl.com/32juca

2000x:
http://tinyurl.com/38q5hh

You`ll find full resolution here:
http://stargazer.christelhager.info/sonic/index.html

now take a look onto this image.
it`s a comparsion between luminance taken with
H16 mono 9"TMB Apo f/9
3 hours

CCD sharp - 2 iterations deconvol. and highpass filter (masking)

and
pseudoluminance taken with M25C (see above)
extracted with channel maixer (1ß%r,80%g,10%b)

the image:
http://tinyurl.com/323gos

...so - what can we learn?
I believe (even the comparion is a bit imperfect,...different focal length,...but I thought it is fair for bayer matrix reason to reducer FL while imaging with M25C)
the difference in resolutionpower of monochrom CCD and color CCD is not so big, as many people claimed...?

best wishes!
Dietmar


Attached Image:

stargazer_7000's attachment for post 36772

clear skies, guys!
Dietmar
---
www.stargazer-observatory.com
Posted 04/21/2007 09:41PM #1
A very interesting comparison,other than image scale I see very little difference as far as details go.I think I actually prefer the psuedoluminance or maybe it is the image scale I prefer,hard to decide because they are both great grin

Your final result is just marvelous!Destined for another pic of the day no doubt!

Keep up the great work so I can keep enjoying looking at it grin

Jason



Posted 04/22/2007 06:27AM #2
A truely remarkable image Dietmar! Color camera or not - that is about the best example of NGC-4631 that I have seen. Well done!

Mike

http://www.DarkSights.com
Posted 04/23/2007 12:22PM #3
Excellent galaxy image, Diets! Another wonderful addition to your collection! You have wonderful results in your experiment as well! I personally still see enough to prefer the pure L over the synthetic L from the luminance, but that's me. grin

Eric