Canon 10D vs. Digital Rebel?

Started by hdlsparky, 05/03/2004 05:49PM
Posted 05/03/2004 05:49PM Opening Post
OK. So I have decided the Canon 10D/Digital Rebel route (over the Nikon D70).

Now the big question is: will the Digital Rebel (300D) do astrophotography as well as the 10D? For those familiar with these two cameras, would the lack of a mirror lock up (among other minor differences) on the Rebel detract from its use for astrophotography when compared to the 10D? How does the CMOS sensor/noise processor in the Rebel compare to the 10D? I understand they are very similar - but are they? How much processing will be required when sing a DSLR as opposed to a dedicated Astro CCD? Any comments or information would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance to all.

By the way, thanks to all for the info on the last post a week or so ago.

Derrick.
Posted 05/04/2004 12:00AM #1
The 10D and 300D have the same sensor, I'm not sure about the processor. The mirror lock up really doesn't come into play unless you are taking planetary or lunar shots and even then it won't make much difference, unless you have a flimsy mount. The other customizable features the 10D has over the 300D are not in use in the "Bulb" mode so it's really a non issue unless you plan on using it for normal photography.
Most of the guys that are taking astro shots with the 10D are using the TC80N3 programable remote. The 300D does not have anything like this so the exposures have to be done manually one at a time, **UNLESS** you want to modify the plug on the TC80N3 to fit the 300D which can be done. There is a diagram floating around on the net and it sounds fairly easy to do.

I have the 300D but have not been able to get out with it because of the weather. I've only taken a couple tripod shots of less than 30sec and it looks good. I plan on shooting the comets with it.


Robert W.

There's no substitute for fine glass!
Posted 05/04/2004 06:56AM #2
Thank you all for the input.

Derrick.
Posted 05/04/2004 05:37PM #3
One other thing about the 10D vs the 300D... the 300D is a lot lighter since it has a plastic body vs the 10D's metal body. It might make a difference if you're close to your weight limit.

Also, software like DSLRFocus and Images Plus can use a specially modified parallel port shutter release cable to emulate the TC80.
Posted 05/05/2004 12:24AM #4
Derrick,

After a long conversation with a rep at the Hutech booth at the NEAF. I'm sold on the 300d (Rebel) until something much more advanced makes its way to the market (in the same price range of course). He was directly involved in the current Digital Rebel modifications. He felt that the Canon is a much better astro camera than the Nikon (at this time)
His modifications for Ha. were also a substantial improvement in image quality.

Best regards,
Tom Tolla

Tom T.
Guilford, CT smile