Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

First CCD shot: a little depressing.

Started by Astrovale, 12/13/2004 03:35PM
Posted 12/13/2004 03:35PM | Edited 12/13/2004 03:57PM Opening Post
Well guys,

I finally was able to take my first CCD shot. It seems like the way will be steep and long! I also had to go through the experience of taking flat fields, since I imaged at F3.3 and all shots had a very noticeable vignetting.
Focusing has been a nightmare, as predicted. I tried to apply some tape to provide diffraction spikes, but they were nowhere to be seen! (how wide should an obstruction be to create proper diffraction spikes?). I am astigmatic so I need an objective tool to judge focus and the brightest pixel offered by CCDOps is not enough.
I also had some problems guiding (my 1st experience) since I could not find a proper guide star. So I had to go unguided and my mount had a hard time tracking at F3.3 for 30 seconds even though my polar alignement is very very good!! So it has not been an easy one for me.
So the attached picture is a crop of the image I took and reduced with a t-shirt flat (alas, not so good, but I have another 4 sets to try out with diffeent average saturation levels). It is 50% the original size (1600x1200) and cropped.


On top of all this I know very little about processing.

Nexstar 11 on APT wedge
.33 FF/FR
SBIG ST-2000 XCM+IDAS LPS
20 5" shots averaged to which I added 10 averaged 30" shots (adding or averaging? I never know which to use!). So it is only a 6 min. exposure.
The ST-2000 XCM "one shot color processing" applies a DDP to the single color channels and I must admit I am not crazy about it (very noticeable dark haloes around stars)but the simple RGB processing provided with the camera software is not great either. I applied only a very light unsh. mask.

Help and advice would be greatly appreciated, as usual.

Ciao
Luca

Attached Image:

Astrovale's attachment for post 20772

www.amun-ra.org
Solar Imaging Website
Posted 12/13/2004 05:23PM #1
Hi Gianluca,

First up, don't dispair, there great images will come with experience.

For focusing, you do not need anything very wide to produce diffraction spikes. I get good spikes from the spider for a normal newtonian. It is possible you did not see them because your star was too faint. Try picking a bright star and using a sub-frame that has the star out of view but the diffraction spikes in view. Your other alternative is to use a mask over the objective with 3 holes. (Hartman mask) When your image is out of focus, you will see 3 images. When in focus you will see one. Some people make one of the holes in a triangular shape so that a diffracton spike is produced. I have never bothered.

I am surprised you could not find a suitable guidestar, especially at f/3.3 an in the M42 region. What sort of exposure were you using?

For processing, I think you would want something better than CCDOpps. There is a wide variety of software available. If you have a win98 machine, MegaFix is quite good, (does not work with winXP) CCDSoft is not bad, although limited. IRIS is freeware that I have not tried. There are many others at various prices.

When it comes to adding or averaging, often it is personal choise. Also some images give better results when added, others when averaged. I often do both (and median) and then see which one looks best.

Hope this helps.

Maurice

* Teach a man to fish and you feed him for a day.
* Teach a man to use the internet and he won't bother you for weeks.
Posted 12/13/2004 05:33PM #2
Gianluca:

I agree with Maurice. It just takes time. I've got the DSI also. I've had more sophisticated models and believe me the DSI is EASY to use compared to some others.

Get the focus down pat (and that isn't easy) and you'll be happy with what you have.

Darrell

"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
Posted 12/13/2004 11:46PM #3
Actually, you have a great shot. I have a 2000XCM and I've played around with the processing for a while. I personaly stay away from the DDP. You need a very strong signal for DDP to do any good or, as you already know, things start lookig weird. Stick with the RGB. If need, boost the contrast up as much as possible. Then finish with photoshop or some othe program that lets you adjust the histogram. If your using the Meade 3.3 reducer get rid of it. Its terrible. I recommend the Astrophysics .67. It work perfectly, no vignetting whatsoever. And it cost about the same as Meade's or Celestron.
Posted 12/14/2004 12:51AM | Edited 12/14/2004 12:51AM #4
Gianluca, you have a very nice FIRST, and many people would be jealous of your first shot alone...

Don't be disappointed if your shots don't look like you want them to, remember that DSOs are VERY HARD to image, and most people here have great experience, with many years of practice... and they are still learning... so don't worry, enjoy the ride! wink


Keep it up!


Ivan
8)

Ivan Gastaldo 8)
Coconut Creek, FL

Ivan's Observatory
Lat 26N 16' 48" Long 80W 10' 48"
[COLOR="Red"]Personal Website:[/COLOR] http://www.ivangastaldo.com

CCD Imaging and Processing/Deep Sky - Moderator
I like to complain about everything - Moderator
Posted 12/14/2004 03:27PM | Edited 12/14/2004 03:57PM #5
Hi Luca,

An excellent image! all you need now is some processing know how. I recommend this article to get you started:

http://www.starrywonders.com/tutorialpage1.html

I believe the reason you couldn't find a reasonable guide star was because of the vignetting you already mentioned. If the imaging chip was severely vignetted, you can rest assured that the guide chip was even worse. I recommend you use an F6.3 corrector/reducer - it has no vignetting. I wouldn't worry about getting pretty diffraction spkies for now. Best to get all the fundamentals going first.

Here's your image with 30 seconds of PhotoShop.

Best,

Jose Suro
Tierra Verde, Florida

Attached Image:

jsuro's attachment for post 85910
Posted 12/15/2004 04:32PM #6
I wanted to thank all of you for the precious suggestions and the even more precious encouragement.

I love this community: always able to find a helping hand!

Ciao and cieli sereni (clear skies in Italian).

Luca

www.amun-ra.org
Solar Imaging Website