Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Teeny Tiny Reflex Red Dots

Started by errnum, 06/07/2009 06:58PM
Posted 06/07/2009 06:58PM | Edited 06/07/2009 07:07PM Opening Post
Have had an inexpensive BSA red dot on the Mark II target pistol a very long time. Has been rugged and can't complain for the price. Then recently put a not-inexpensive EOTECH Holosight on a rifle. Can't say enough good things about the EOTECH.

Being a reflex type of sight, if you can see the dot in the EOTECH, the bullet will go there. The old $40 BSA is not a reflex sight, and unless the dot is in the middle of the sight, the bullet ain't gonna go where the dot is. I'll never be a really accurate shooter, but there was a certain limit to basic accuracy with the Mark II that had to do with improperly getting the dot exactly centered in the sight frame.

Recently the battery went down on the BSA and I didn't have a spare onhand, so used the Mark II iron sights. The iron sights shot somewhat more accurate than the BSA red dot, but my eyes are old and the iron sights are very difficult to see, especially against certain target colors. Black sights against a black bullseye, no fun. OTOH, paint a white rim on the sights, that would suck against a white bullseye. Since I was having so much trouble even SEEING the ruger iron sights, and still shot (a little bit) better than the BSA red dot, then the parallax issue on the BSA must be pretty significant in the 25 foot ballpark, unless the dot is precisely centered in the frame.

I like iron sights on the higher-caliber pistols because accuracy expectations are lower. If the majority of 9mm or .357 shots can hit a paper plate at 25 feet, hey wish it was better but that is not too bad for an old guy. With the .22 pistol, the acceptable grouping is much smaller than the size of the iron sights against the target.

As an experiment, I drew a black Sharpie Marks-on-Anything dot precisely in the center of the front glass of the BSA red dot sight. Test-shooting, the accuracy was very good if I superimpose the black dot and red dot on the bullseye. So precisely centering the red dot helps a great deal. However, the sharpie-drawn black dot is difficult to see against dark target backgrounds. Maybe some kind of tiny red ring could be inscribed on a disk of plastic or glass, and mounted on the front of the BSA. Maybe that would be more easily visible than an opaque black dot. Superimpose the red dot on the red ring on the bullseye.

On a rifle, it might be easier to reliably center the red dot in a non-reflex sight, and at rifle distances perhaps the parallax would not be so bad. Dunno.

However, instant gratification would be to replace the BSA with a reflex sight. Another EOTECH for the Mark II would be nice, except the EOTECH costs about the same as the pistol, and it is a little on the heavy side. Supposedly the model 511 is discontinued but still available around $380.



Bushnell sells a Gen II holosight you can get around $300 some places, which is essentially identical (made by the same USA company) except lacking the metal protective hood. $80 is a lot of money to pay for an extra piece of aluminum but OTOH one would wish for the metal hood the first time inevitably whacking the sight against something hard.



Many reflex sights have a separate 'screen' sticking up that appears begging to break off if you unfortunately catch that obstruction against something:



A well-reviewed sight that looks similar to my BSA is the Nikon Monarch. But I can't find any reference claiming the Monarch is a reflex sight, so maybe its great on rifles/shotguns and not so great on pistols.



A small light 'Pistol Sized' reflex sight that doesn't get horrible reviews looks like this:



And then here is obviously 'about the same thing' less expensive:



That style uses 'auto brightness', and the biggest user review complaints have to do with the auto brightness circuitry automatically setting the wrong brightness, so that doesn't sound great. The ultra-cheap units that 'look like the big boys' get bad reviews for breaking easily or not holding aim point.

Looking for small pistol-size but not pinching pennies, nobody seriously complains about the Aimpoint Micro, which doesn't have any parts to snag and break off and has a manual brightness knob:



Aha, but then there is a Sig asian clone (OTOH, maybe the Aimpoint is imported too, dunno):



Poking around, it has been alleged that the ITac Defense company is owned by Sig and was created to handle imported items like this. Dunno, that is just what has been claimed. The ITac branded looks an awful lot like the Sig, dunno if it is in every way identical. Costs less:



And then it gets very inexpensive (compared to the above) with the Konus Sight-Pro Atomic Electronic Red Dot Sight. Same published specs, $82. And ya gotta love that product name.



One would expect that the more expensive versions somehow work better or are more reliable. Or would one? Maybe the Konus rotary switch is less reliable than the ITac, Sig or Aimpoint? Maybe the Konus will fall apart from recoil or not hold aimpoint or eats batteries in 10 minutes or has a dot that looks like a comet?


Posted 06/09/2009 02:45PM #1
James,
Quite a post there my friend! I am still struggling with deciding which "red dot" to go with after doing some extensive research on them. It comes down to the price and what I am truly going to use it for...or do I want to go all tacticool and get me an EOTech or Aimpoint, which sometimes can cost as much as the rifle (AR15) itself, especially throwing a 3x magnifier behind it.

I still haven't owned any holographic sight to-date. My money is better invested elsewhere for the time being as iron sights are sufficient given the short range shooting that I usually do. I sold the SIG sight that came with my P556 because I did not like how spread out the "dot" was. I have a cheap Famous Maker red dot on my AR, but in pains me somewhat to have such a cheap thing on a nice S&W M&P15T. I'm actually thinking Bushnell holosight since they are made by L3, just like the EOTech. I've seen them sold new 2nd hand, for around $200 and usually can be had for $240 or so.

Tri
Posted 06/10/2009 04:19AM #2
I have an Aimpoint Micro T1 on a Remington Shotgun (I think I posted a picture of that on this forum). It is a super little sight and puts the round on target no matter where your head is (so long as you can see the dot). I wonder about the cheaper knock-offs...... but maybe someone has tried them and will report.

One thing I like about the Aimpoint is the battery life.......1000's X hours of life. You can basically turn it on and store the gun, you'd have to replace the batteries every 5 years or so.

Nice post!

Mike

http://www.DarkSights.com