Image of the day

Captured by
james carter

North American Nebula NGC7000

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Communication in desert

Started by progenitor, 03/28/2006 03:32AM
Posted 03/28/2006 03:32AM Opening Post
I was on a 2,800 mi trip recently around the SW National Parks. I learned how my mobile phone is limited as a communication mean as it was out of signal most of the time.
If I would undertake a similar trip in the future with the kids, I definitely would like have the way to call for help if in trouble. What shall I look for on the market ?
Posted 03/28/2006 03:26PM #1
Thanks Bob, now can you somehow quantify the $$ ? Maybe it would be cheaper just to lease a satellite phone for the trips wink ?
Posted 04/03/2006 03:07AM #2
While amateur radio is great for many communications needs, it is not always the "best" solution for the problems mentioned. Just as you must be in range of a cell phone tower to use a cell phone, you must be in range of a VHF or UHF repeater to use your ham radio (unless you mean HF, which entails a great deal more expense for mobile use). Of course you can use simplex, but that means someone must be monitoring the frequency within the simplex range, which is essentially line-of-sight. Even assuming you are within range of a repeater, there is not always someone monitoring remote repeaters to respond to a call, and there may not be an autopatch on the repeater. Then there is the prohibition on commercial calls on an autopatch unless it is an emergency.

Ham radio is a great hobby, and without question the most reliable means of communication in a true emergency (like last year's hurricanes), but if I did a lot of back-country solo 4-wheeling or hiking a satellite phone would be high on my list of necessities. Remember the guy who was solo hiking in Utah a couple of years ago and got his hand caught under a boulder? After three or four days with no food or water, he ended up cutting his arm off with a pocket knife so he could reach help. His chances of getting help would have been much greater with a satellite phone. Of course that would assume that the phone could see a satellite from a narrow, steep canyon.

73 de Jim WD5BKO