Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Mewlon 180

Started by slick50, 08/28/2009 04:14AM
Posted 08/28/2009 04:14AM | Edited 08/30/2009 12:02AM Opening Post
Greetings all,

Well with all the talk about Mewlons I had to post some musings.

Nothing spectacular, but I was viewing Jupiter the other night and the view was pretty good but the seeing was not up to snuff because of the heat here in the desert. It did improve as the night when on but I can not stay up to late because I have work in the morning.

But some interesting notes:

1. I just got the Mewlon back from TNR where they gave it the once over. So I haven't use it in a while and, in fact, haven't used it too much since I got it. But I was struck by two things: 1. How black the sky background was 2. How small the stars were. This later point is of significant note as, for example, the stars in the double double were little orbs that fluctuated only slightly with the seeing, much better than Jupiter. While one would expect stars to hold up better it just stuck in my head how compact and well formed they were. I have never had a view like this in any other compound telescope I have looked through. I did own a TEC6 before, but it was a while ago so I can't really remember the views with any clarity.

2. Collimation: Interesting experience here. Having just been shipped back, it was a little out so I decided to go for perfection. A half hour later I had made a complete mess out of the star test. This is actually pretty unusual for me as I have collimated many scopes over the years and never considered it that difficult, but on this night it got away from me.

So what to do? Well I took the scope off the mount and brought it inside. I set it on the counter and removed the diagonal. Staring down the visual back I simply made the reflecting circle containing a reflection of my eye concentric with the circular opening of the visual back. By the way, in doing this you could immediately see how badly out it was. But in just a couple minutes everything was concentric. Took it back outside and guess what - DEAD ON!

Again, just some musing that may be helpful to some with some thought about the night's experiences. Others have said it and it clearly is true, for a folded optic with the central obstruction a Mewlon has the airy discs are very small (a function of aperture as well of course) but very clean. Really surprising.

And I think there is a lesson there. Many will cry, "with that kind of central obstruction it can't be any better than an SCT." But I think it's not that Mewlons are defying physics, it's that our expectations have been reduced by poor execution in some mainstream scopes. Clearly, with attention to detail and optical quality, even in a scope with a fairly large obstruction, one can achieve crisp clean images with superb contrast.

Take care,
john
Posted 08/29/2009 02:15PM | Edited 08/30/2009 05:41AM #1
John
I receive my "Ugly M-180" and the clouds finally cleared for a while. The seeing wasn't very good, but I was able to observe enough to know there is nothing ugly about the optics on this thing. To my relief, it appears to have arrived well colimated. The Feathertouch focuser is proving to be a nice addition. I can tell that the Nagler 13 Type 6 is going to get a lot of use with this scope.

I'm excited to see it perform on a night of good to great seeing. Especially if Jupiter is still up.
Thanks
Steven Jindra