Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

2x and 3x Barlow

Started by blueflagella, 03/23/2004 08:03PM
Posted 03/23/2004 08:03PM Opening Post
What kind of visual difference could one expect to see using the same eyepiece in a 2x 2" Barlow as in a 3x 2" Barlow? Would the visual difference depend on the eyepieces magnification? I tested 9mm, 16.8mm, 25mm, 30mm, and 42mm eyepieces quickly swapping them out with the 2x and the 3x Barlows. I could not differentiate between the two. I first looked at the orion nebeula, then Jupiter, and then on a street light with all 5 eyepieces. Did I just get a 3x barlow that is really only 2x or is the difference that negligable, and if so then why would one want varying magnifications in barlows? By the way my scope is 8" f/6 1200mm if that matters. I am realy confused.
Please Help,
Todd
Posted 03/23/2004 09:15PM #1
Todd,

There's no way you could test a 9mm EP (normally 133x in your scope) and not see the difference between 267x and 399x! You must have a 2x improperly labled as a 3x. What brand is it?
Posted 03/23/2004 09:45PM #2
Are the two barlows the same brand? The rated magnification of various designs can actually vary somewhat from the claimed numbers; apparently Celestron's Ultima Barlow is closer to 2.3x, if I recall correctly.

It's POSSIBLE that if your 2x is actually a little higher and your 3x is actually a little lower, they might be pretty close. Seems a little unlikely, though.

Something seems fishy, at any rate. Try looking at things in the daylight, like the side of distant building. That'll give you plenty of reference points to see if the magnifications are changing.
Posted 03/24/2004 01:47AM #3
Todd, could you PLEASE let us know WHAT you have for barlow lenses?
Between a 2x and a 3x THERE IS a difference...


Let us know,



Ivan

Ivan Gastaldo 8)
Coconut Creek, FL

Ivan's Observatory
Lat 26N 16' 48" Long 80W 10' 48"
[COLOR="Red"]Personal Website:[/COLOR] http://www.ivangastaldo.com

CCD Imaging and Processing/Deep Sky - Moderator
I like to complain about everything - Moderator
Posted 03/24/2004 03:48PM #4
Hi Todd.

In the past, I've done an experiment similar in spirit to the suggestion to look at the side of a building, though I don't know whether your scope and circumstances would allow it. If you can focus on a yardstick (or tape measure?) that extends all the way across your field of view, you can note the width of your field "in inches" (or cm) with and without a barlow. The 2x barlow should decrease the field width by roughly a factor of 2 and the 3x by roughly a factor of 3. If you try this experiment and find that the 2x and 3x barlows are decreasing your field width by the same amount, one of them is lying about its magnification and you should be able to tell which one.

Hope this helps,
John