Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Best 4" APO

Started by Jagpel, 01/06/2004 11:21PM
Posted 01/06/2004 11:21PM Opening Post
Hello:

I'm looking for some advice, what is the best fast 4" APO in the market for wide field, planets and double stars, easy transportation.

Thanks

JAG
Posted 01/06/2004 11:44PM #1
New to this forum? You'll never get a reliable answer to this question. Heck, we can't even agree on what constitutes APO ;-) Probably can't agree on what constitutes "fast" either. My definition of fast would be f7 or less (others would probably disagree).

TeleVue, Astro Physics, Takahashi are three vendors with big followings who make quality APO refractors. The Televue has a field flattner built in (good for astrophotography), the Astro Physics has to be purchased used (the wait is well over 3 years from today if you're not already on the list), all the Tak's are great (doublets FS102 does have a bit more color than the Televue 101(two doublets) and AP105(triplet)) and the one Tak TOA (ED triplet - available now only in 5" it think, but 4" coming) was supurb. Very few observers could discern much difference between the 3 and even fewer if the weren't side by side.

Vixen, Brandon (I think), William Optics, Stellarvue, TEC/CNC (from Markus Ludes) also make APO refractors in this price/performance range as well.

I'd scour these forums for past threads to help you narrow the field, then try to look through some personally. It is a ton of money to spend "sight unseen".

They all weigh 8-15 pounds, so transportation isn't really much of a factor with these scopes. The AP105 is the shortest, lightest and the most expensive if you want it soon (maybe the cheapest if you willing to wait).

I have the William Optics FLT110 (ED triplet). Mine is great, throws up an excellent star test w/almost no false color in any situation. It is also beautifully made (but not quite Takahashi like) though some gripe about the focuser smoothness in cold weather. I bought one after seeing one at a star party and it is was about $800 cheaper than the Tak FSQ106 (double doublet) similarly equiped. Optics made by TEC (Golden Colorado) and ota/focuser made in asia.
Posted 01/06/2004 11:53PM #2
The Astro Physics and TV 4 inch apos always get rave reviews for quality. I have a TV np 101 primarily due to its relatively small size and light weight (29" long and weighing 11.3 lbs with the 2" diagonal attached), but you pay a considerable premium for shaving off those few extra lbs. There are lots of competing products in the 4" apo refractor market and asking for the best one is sort of like asking for the best pie recipe. Better have your check book ready when the answers roll in.
Posted 01/07/2004 12:06AM #3
All of the 4" APOs that have been talked about are great,you would probably be happy with any one of them. I think that the Tak FS102 is most likely the the best deal right now, if money is a issue.
Posted 01/07/2004 02:28AM #4
Hi Jose,

I have a Vixen 102EDSS f6.5 and the Vixen Fluorite f9. The f9 is color-free in focus and is an excellent performer. The f6.5 does exhibit color, to my eye, on stars of first magnitude and brighter. On planets the ED appears to give a slightly warmer image than the Fluorite but the difference between the two scopes is far less than some things I have read would indicate. The 102EDSS is no NP101, TMB 6.5, or Traveler but a used one is $1200 or less. They are a heck of a nice scope at that price and are very light in weight, about 7 lbs.

Cleart Skies,

Steve
Posted 01/07/2004 05:17AM #5
Jose,

I would agree that the best 4" apo for the money right now is a used Tak FS 102. On AM you can pick one up with the essential accessories for around the $1600-1700 range. But personally IMHO the best with no compromise is the TMB 100/800. They are NLA so you will have to get one on the used market. I have one and the views are stunning with no color and wonderful contrast. It can take absurd mag if seeing permits and it is BV ready straight thru sans a corrector/barlow. I have the CNC model which I prefer to the LW OTA. But on the flip side, the LW OTA is probably easier to transport and you can't argue about the Feathertouch focuser. You can get nice wide views with an f8 but any FL shorter than that, I think would compromise lunar/planetary and doubles viewing.

Have fun surfing the learning curve on APOs, (I've never looked thru one that I didn't like)

Owen
Posted 01/07/2004 08:12AM #6
I take it you are saying fast because you want a short tube easy to transport, and APO because you don't like false color flaring and dark inky black backgrounds. If that's really your criteria, then perhaps a 6" MK67 may be the best apo, plus 50% more aperture, still under 10 pounds! Wink wink. Kidding but kind of not really. Have you considered a russian mak for your needs? Check out ITE or cloudynights.com
Posted 01/07/2004 08:49PM #7
I'm going to put in a plug for a used TV 102. It's not exactly "fast" at F/8.6 but can achieve a 3-degree field with a 55mm plossl eyepiece, and an F/6.9 field flattener is available for photography. It's lightweight, not bulky, excellent on planets and double stars, and I've seen them on Astromart for as little as $1650...a lot of bang for the buck, IMO!
Posted 01/07/2004 10:02PM #8
The premium scopes seem to hold their value quite well, but as mentioned in several posts there are good deals to be had in the resale market. I've purchased (and eventually resold for lack of use) a Questar and a Teleport from Astromart at a considerable savings. Each was a few years old but in beautiful condition. There were a number of TV 101s for sale when the np 101 was released, and TV np 101s started coming up for sale when the TV 127 was released. If you decide on a particular scope try posting a 'scope wanted' ad on Astromart before you buy new, yuo may be surprised at what you can get.
Posted 01/13/2004 01:26AM #9
Ah, perhaps you could read the other 50,000 posts and arguments that have errupted over this topic. I guess it can't help but rear its ugly head every few weeks.