Curved Spiders

Started by fblue, 03/19/2005 11:49PM
Posted 03/19/2005 11:49PM Opening Post
I know this has been discussed before, but I would like to hear from those who have actually installed them on their scopes and used them. I specifically would like to know about planetary detail compared to the straight vanes, not the pleasing look, but the hard facts about the actual details seen on planets with the two different spiders.
I am considering one for my new ZZ-10 scope and would like to hear about your experiences pro or con.

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 03/20/2005 12:05AM #1
Hi Floyd,

I made a curved spider for a 10" dob I had a few years back. It did get rid of the diffraction spikes. I wanted this, not for esthetic reasons, but in hopes of being able to split some close doubles. I was going after the Pup, which was very difficult with 10" at that time (still pretty darned difficult).

Well, it got rid of the spikes, but I noticed no real improvement in being able to make tight splits. IMO, since diffraction spikes don't really bug me, I saw no advantage. I can't say the overall contrast was worse, but I do tend to believe that diffraction still occurs with a curved spider, but is merely spread across a wider area. Again, just me, but unless I were doing some serious AP, I wouldn't bother. Actually, I personally still would not bother, but that is just my opinion and I am aware that many use and love curved spiders.

Randy

Randy Roy
Posted 03/21/2005 02:41PM #2
Floyd -
Head over to Cloudy Nights - there is a very long thread in the equipment forum that has a lot of info on this:
http://www.cloudynights.com/ubbthreads/showflat.php/Cat/0/Number/360923/page/0/view/collapsed/sb/5/o/all/fpart/1

You might want to do a quick search through the reflector and ATM forums as well - there have been various threads on curved spiders in both over the last year or so. Too much info to repost here.

Jarad

Posted 03/21/2005 06:28PM #3
Hi, Floyd, I installed a Protostar single arch secondary support in my 8-inch f/8 Newt last year, replacing a Novak four-vane spider. Definitely gets rid of the diffraction spikes, but do I see more planetary detail? Difficult to prove one way or the other, since I am limited by the atmosphere virtually all the time. Images were very good before, they’re very good now. I like the aesthetics of not having diffraction spikes, though.

Compared against a good four vane spider with thin vanes (like a Novak), a four curved vane spider will probably add total diffraction, three vanes will probably be a wash, and a single arch will probably reduce total diffraction. A curved vane spider is useful in eliminating the diffraction spikes, but IMHO its effect on planetary detail is marginal at best.

Good luck deciding! grin
Doug
Posted 03/21/2005 07:15PM #4
Unfortunately since going to curved vanes is usually a "before & after" comparison, rather than a side-by-side blind test, it's hard to objectively say -- when I went to curved vanes on my 10" the spikes disappeared and things look 'contrasty' but not being able to do a side-by-side I cannot honestly say whether actual planetary detail was influenced, one way or the other.
Posted 03/21/2005 08:39PM #5
Hi Floyd. I have the Protostar single curve spider on my 10" Royce newt and I love it. It is a bit tricky to install but nothing serious. I enjoy the lack of diffraction spikes. As far as any contrast gains, I really cant tell the difference but planetary images sure look nice. I would never go back to a straight vane on that scope, I like the curve that much. An added bonus is that when your hunting down Phobos and Deimos, or other dim moons, they cant hide in the bright diffration spikes. Vince
Posted 03/22/2005 05:46AM #6
Floyd,
First, the long answer:
Dick Suiter and William Zmek did a very nice article on spider diffraction in ATM Journal issue #11. If you can get your hands on a copy, it's a good read. If not contact me via a-marts' private message.
Suiter's analysis showed that a true semi-circle spider most evenly distributes the diffraction over the entire field. Only one spider maker I know of makes this design and since I don't see them listed as a sponser they shall remain nameless. I tried to make one and it came out too 'springy' and thus a poor support. I did talk to someone at Novak when I ordered my last 2 spiders (curved of course) and asked if they had tried the design. They responed that they had the same stability issues I had, so they stuck with thier old design.

Now the short response,, I hope.
All 3 of my newts have Novak curved vane spiders.
My 10" was built that way so I have no comparison to make.
My 4-1/4" went from a single stalk to a 2 vane curved. Huge improvement but unfair comparison.
My 6" went from a Novak 4 vane straight to a 2 vane curved. Nine years straight and 2 years curved. As Paul mentioned, without a side by side comparison I think it would be impossible to to rate planetary performance. My best views with that scope were with the straight vane spider, but that was due to seeing conditions and not spider diffraction.

with a spikeless preference,
Bob

Fujinon 10x70 FMT-SX binocs
Tak FS-78 ƒ/8.1 - 630mm fl.
6" ƒ/6.5 homeground newt. - 981mm fl.
10" ƒ/4.85 homeground dob. - 1231mm fl.



Posted 03/22/2005 01:18PM #7
For what it's worth diffraction analysis in Zemax doesn't show any improvement in the diffraction disk using curved spiders.

Ed Jones