Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Differences in OIII filters

Started by Eddie Kirkland, 11/17/2004 08:28PM
Posted 11/17/2004 08:28PM Opening Post
I have a Thousand Oaks OIII filter and have been very happy with it for over a year......until last week at the Chiefland Star Party where an aquaintance and I compaired my T.O. and his older Lumicon in my 16" f/4.5 dob with filter slide on the Veil Nebula. While the difference was not great, his Lumicon obviously bested my T.O.; we both agreed on that; enough that I'm thinking of replacing my T.O. While talking to a knowledgable vendor later that night he stated that he and others had tested several OIII filters and arrived at this performance order: Televue>old Lumicon>T.O>new Lumicon/Parks. Has anyone else run a similar shootout on OIII filters? What were your results? How about UHC/Ultrablock filters?

Thanks for any insights,
Eddie
Posted 11/17/2004 09:19PM #1
I compared a Lumicon (from 2001) with a new Astronomik OIII in my 12.5 f/6 reflector on a couple of occasions. In skies with a LVM of ~5.8, I could detect no difference between them. Only in very transparent skies (LVM ~6.4) did the Lumicon show it had much better contrast on the veil nebula.

I was able to test both filters with a spectrometer and the bandwidth on the Astronomik was wider than the Lumicon and this showed less colouring of stars, was a little brighter and seemed to be more appropriate for smaller aperture scopes.

Here is a website that shows some results from spectral transmission tests with some different deep sky filters.
http://home.freeuk.com/m.gavin/grism2.htm

Gary Weber

Posted 11/17/2004 09:34PM #2
I'm afraid I'm lost here: does your scale mean that Televue has the best or the worst of the OIII filters???