Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Finder Scope Blues

Started by bdws1975, 08/02/2005 07:04PM
Posted 08/02/2005 07:04PM Opening Post
sad
Yikes! I just recently bought an Orion SkyQuest XT8 Classic and it is a wonderful telescope....except for the blinking finder scope. I feel as though I have been twisted into a pretzel after a few hours trying to see the Ring Nebula in Lyra.
I am considering buying a 45 degree angle 9 x 50. What is the best brand for the money? Also, I have heard a lot about the Telrad. Is this a replacement for a finder? I would appreciate any advice.
I figure I might as well spring for a new finder or I will be spending a significantly larger amount of money on the chiropractor.

Thanks,
Brett
Posted 08/02/2005 09:23PM #1
Lots of people like RA finders. Personally I like straight thru finders because I can keep both my eyes open and point the scope at the target with the unmagnified eye first and once the target is in the finder I can zero in on it.

A good chair like a Starbound makes using the scope and the finder in particular much more comfortable and less awkward.

On the other hand, the XT-8 classic comes with a 6x30 finder if I am not mistaken, upgrading to an 8x50 RA would be a reasonable thing to do. The ORion RA finder would be a good choice because you can use the same dovetail mounting on the scope.

jon
Posted 08/02/2005 09:31PM #2
Hi Brett,

The Telrad is indispensable! When I pass into the great void, I'm taking my Telrad and some batteries! grin

There really is no better locator for most visual work. Much faster with less puttzing around. Some will use an actual finder after the telrad to locate dim globs, etc. but the telrad will get you within .5* so who needs a finder unless you only use 200X+ in the main scope.

All my scopes have a Telrad and have had for 15+ years. Edmund sold a bull's eye wheat lamp in a metal cast body in the 50's. Same principle as the Telrad. My brother and I used this one for years . It weighed more than our scope and was still worth the fuss.

Thanks,
John
Posted 08/03/2005 12:33AM #3
I have a 6" Orion XT, and the straight finder was killing my neck and back to the point were I wouldn't use the scope any more, the solution is you need a Right angle finder and a red dot finder or telrad, use the red dot or telrad to get you close then the right angle finder to fine tune.

This works fine for me.

A telrad would help to help you to starhop by using the rings of the telrad to determine how far to move in a given direction. But I agree other post the telrad requires darks skys were the red dot works fairly well if used with both eyes open.


Frank
Posted 08/03/2005 02:23AM #4
I would recomend getting a 50mm finder. You see more stars and deep sky objects in them then in a 30mm. As a bonus I 50 mm finders, under my skies at least, show the same stars as Sky Atlas 2000 so I'm all set.

I use a straight through finder on my 10" dob. I sight over the tube to get in the area then look through the finder to get it where I need to go.

If you must have a RA finder do get a unit power finder to go with it. There's a load of them on the market right now and I recomend one of the real simple red dot models like Stellarvue or Antares sells. They seem to have the biggest window to look through. Plus, they weight about a 1/3 or 1/4 of what a Telrad weighs.

Hope this helps.

Eric
Posted 08/03/2005 04:36AM #5
Rigel Red dot finder combined with Orion 6x30 RA Correct Image finder works great on my Discovery 8" dob. The Rigel quickly gets me into the general neighborhood. The optical finder puts me on specific targets without having to change back to low power eyepieces.

As for the optical finder, correct image and 6x30 make it easier to match the image to the star chart. Bigger finders clutter the field with stars that aren't on the charts making a match more difficult. Correct Image elmininates the mental up/down, left/right flips (it's late, I'm tired, OK?).

The 6x30 is also light enough so that a lightweight red dot finder can be added without messing up the scope's balance.

Right Angle makes the finder much easier to use without contortion. Mount the finder so you can easily transfer between scope e.p. and the finder while seated. Very nice for slowly working your way around a constellation exploring every nook and cranny.
Bob

Posted 08/03/2005 04:57AM #6
I vote for a 9x50 right angle plus a red dot easy finder stuck to the tube. On my light polluted skies, the red dot will put me onto any 4th mag star. Then I use the 9x50 RA to star hop around up and can see 8th mag relatively easily. Also the 9x50 will put anything into view onto even my 240x field (1/4 deg FOV) of the primary's eyepiece without going down in power...
Posted 08/03/2005 05:45AM | Edited 08/03/2005 05:48AM #7
Get one of these:

http://www.stellarvue.com/f50.html

It is the best telescope accessory I have ever gotten. It makes finding anything a breeze and a joy. No more contorting, wrenching your neck, etc. It is very easy to use. Point your scope along the horizon toward what you want to look at, and sweep upward until you get the major features in the field of view (bright stars, whatever). Then center the crosshairs on the target, and voila!
Posted 08/03/2005 12:28PM #8
My two cents... I have an 8" dob that came with a 9x50 finder. I used that for a few months and was frustrated as anything because it showed *so* many stars, I couldn't find what I was looking for. So I got a Telrad and used both, until the finder's mounting bracket broke off. I've used the Telrad only for a year and a half now, even in seriously light polluted skies, and haven't even missed the finder. I've been able to find things in town by using the few bright stars visible and the Telrad to get in the right area, then finding the target in a low-power ep. Works for me.
Yes, it's true, there's still some contortion involved looking through the Telrad, but it's a much faster process (at least now that I'm used to the thing), so fewer overall neck cramps. 8)

~Denise
Posted 08/03/2005 01:52PM #9
Consider a "dew shield plus" for the Telrad. The "plus" includes a mirror that allows right-angle use of the Telrad, eliminating the contortion, but it is a bit finicky to position correctly.