Hi All:
I am starting this thread to help hone in on a new scope purchase. I am down to the wire. :S I requested info in this vein once before in another thread (Wanted: Opinions on an Exceptional Planetary). I was kind of set on a Goto Truss Dob with premium optics (either TScopes 13” or Spacewalk 12.5”). The 14.5” Starmaster w/ GoTo & Tracking was a bit pricey compared to the others. I was almost ready - until perusing the APO vs. Reflector thread in the Reflectors forum.
After reviewing that thread, particularly in light of some of Roland Christen’s and Gordon Dayton’s posts, I am reconsidering a larger MakCass (MK 91), possibly a MakNewt. The only reasonably priced option for a large MakCass I am finding is the MK91. Mike Palermiti @ ITE can make a graphite tube version, saving me about 9 pounds, and more importantly – the necessity of a new mount! Going up 1” to ITE’s M10F10 doubles the price. Ditto TEC’s MakCass’s of 8” – 10”.
So, here are my concerns. Number 1 – Wife: She wants this to be my last – ultimate scope – she thinks I’m kidding when I explain I need to buy a Keck. Suffice it to say, this will need to last a while – 2 + years.
My primary interest is planetary (This could change with a larger dob). The MK91 has a 3100mm FL – allowing the use of longer FL EP’s. BUT – a 12” or 13” Dob will have a larger exit pupil. Which wins out?
Roland Christen pointed out some downsides of the Truss Dob – necessity of frequent collimation, unprotected optics need cleaning & recoating. I don’t have much time to view – the relative “ease” of a larger MakCass may be attractive. How long will it take to start viewing with a truss dob? I won’t be going to a dark site – just the yard. Do I need to collimate each time out?
How often is recoating needed to maintain reasonably premium performance?
Premium dob owners – when viewing planets – do you use small FL EP’s, or do you Barlow / Powermate?
In the end - it all comes down to the views. Opinions? Which are better – with an emphasis on contrast. In my opinion – Jupiter is the real test.
I guess I’d really like to know the CONS of each scope. Please feel free to expound upon the virtues of one over the other – but I’d really like to know the cons.
One other option – anyone have any opinions regarding the new Starmaster V-11. Rick Singmaster advised in a e-mail he would start taking orders in about a month. Has anyone seen / used the V-8? I am guessing a G-11 Gemini would be in order for the V-11.
V-11 / G-11 sounds kind of cool.
Should I just wait a little longer and try for the 14.5 Starmater w/ Zambuto?
I now have "paralysis by analysis."
Thanks in advance.
Gregg
MK67 / LXD55
PST
I am starting this thread to help hone in on a new scope purchase. I am down to the wire. :S I requested info in this vein once before in another thread (Wanted: Opinions on an Exceptional Planetary). I was kind of set on a Goto Truss Dob with premium optics (either TScopes 13” or Spacewalk 12.5”). The 14.5” Starmaster w/ GoTo & Tracking was a bit pricey compared to the others. I was almost ready - until perusing the APO vs. Reflector thread in the Reflectors forum.
After reviewing that thread, particularly in light of some of Roland Christen’s and Gordon Dayton’s posts, I am reconsidering a larger MakCass (MK 91), possibly a MakNewt. The only reasonably priced option for a large MakCass I am finding is the MK91. Mike Palermiti @ ITE can make a graphite tube version, saving me about 9 pounds, and more importantly – the necessity of a new mount! Going up 1” to ITE’s M10F10 doubles the price. Ditto TEC’s MakCass’s of 8” – 10”.
So, here are my concerns. Number 1 – Wife: She wants this to be my last – ultimate scope – she thinks I’m kidding when I explain I need to buy a Keck. Suffice it to say, this will need to last a while – 2 + years.
My primary interest is planetary (This could change with a larger dob). The MK91 has a 3100mm FL – allowing the use of longer FL EP’s. BUT – a 12” or 13” Dob will have a larger exit pupil. Which wins out?
Roland Christen pointed out some downsides of the Truss Dob – necessity of frequent collimation, unprotected optics need cleaning & recoating. I don’t have much time to view – the relative “ease” of a larger MakCass may be attractive. How long will it take to start viewing with a truss dob? I won’t be going to a dark site – just the yard. Do I need to collimate each time out?
How often is recoating needed to maintain reasonably premium performance?
Premium dob owners – when viewing planets – do you use small FL EP’s, or do you Barlow / Powermate?
In the end - it all comes down to the views. Opinions? Which are better – with an emphasis on contrast. In my opinion – Jupiter is the real test.
I guess I’d really like to know the CONS of each scope. Please feel free to expound upon the virtues of one over the other – but I’d really like to know the cons.
One other option – anyone have any opinions regarding the new Starmaster V-11. Rick Singmaster advised in a e-mail he would start taking orders in about a month. Has anyone seen / used the V-8? I am guessing a G-11 Gemini would be in order for the V-11.
V-11 / G-11 sounds kind of cool.
Should I just wait a little longer and try for the 14.5 Starmater w/ Zambuto?
I now have "paralysis by analysis."
Thanks in advance.
Gregg
MK67 / LXD55
PST