Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

HELP - Truss Dob v MakCass

Started by GregDamiani, 07/31/2005 10:48PM
Posted 07/31/2005 10:48PM Opening Post
Hi All:

I am starting this thread to help hone in on a new scope purchase. I am down to the wire. :S I requested info in this vein once before in another thread (Wanted: Opinions on an Exceptional Planetary). I was kind of set on a Goto Truss Dob with premium optics (either TScopes 13” or Spacewalk 12.5”). The 14.5” Starmaster w/ GoTo & Tracking was a bit pricey compared to the others. I was almost ready - until perusing the APO vs. Reflector thread in the Reflectors forum.

After reviewing that thread, particularly in light of some of Roland Christen’s and Gordon Dayton’s posts, I am reconsidering a larger MakCass (MK 91), possibly a MakNewt. The only reasonably priced option for a large MakCass I am finding is the MK91. Mike Palermiti @ ITE can make a graphite tube version, saving me about 9 pounds, and more importantly – the necessity of a new mount! Going up 1” to ITE’s M10F10 doubles the price. Ditto TEC’s MakCass’s of 8” – 10”.

So, here are my concerns. Number 1 – Wife: She wants this to be my last – ultimate scope – she thinks I’m kidding when I explain I need to buy a Keck. Suffice it to say, this will need to last a while – 2 + years.

My primary interest is planetary (This could change with a larger dob). The MK91 has a 3100mm FL – allowing the use of longer FL EP’s. BUT – a 12” or 13” Dob will have a larger exit pupil. Which wins out?

Roland Christen pointed out some downsides of the Truss Dob – necessity of frequent collimation, unprotected optics need cleaning & recoating. I don’t have much time to view – the relative “ease” of a larger MakCass may be attractive. How long will it take to start viewing with a truss dob? I won’t be going to a dark site – just the yard. Do I need to collimate each time out?

How often is recoating needed to maintain reasonably premium performance?

Premium dob owners – when viewing planets – do you use small FL EP’s, or do you Barlow / Powermate?

In the end - it all comes down to the views. Opinions? Which are better – with an emphasis on contrast. In my opinion – Jupiter is the real test.

I guess I’d really like to know the CONS of each scope. Please feel free to expound upon the virtues of one over the other – but I’d really like to know the cons.

One other option – anyone have any opinions regarding the new Starmaster V-11. Rick Singmaster advised in a e-mail he would start taking orders in about a month. Has anyone seen / used the V-8? I am guessing a G-11 Gemini would be in order for the V-11.

V-11 / G-11 sounds kind of cool.

Should I just wait a little longer and try for the 14.5 Starmater w/ Zambuto?

I now have "paralysis by analysis."

Thanks in advance.

Gregg
MK67 / LXD55
PST
Posted 07/31/2005 11:11PM #1
A hi end MAK- in the 8" to 10" size with a top notch mount is gonna cost some big bucks, say around $8000 to $15000! You can get a nice 12.5" to 15" Dob with GO- TO for around $6000 to $9000.

I am a planet nut, and have owned five Starmasters & 15" Obssesion, they have been the best scopes i've ever used on the planets. You can wheel out a complete Dob with wheel barrow handles,and be looking in less than five mins! I always have to fine tune collimation with my Dobs, takes about 3 mins with collimation tools.

I can use powers well over 800x on nites of super seeing, and trust me with excellent optics, the detail on the planets with a larger scope is unreal!

I think a 14.5" Starmaster with GO-TO tracking, or a 15" Obsession with the OMI- torus optics, would be about the best planet scope there is for under $10,000.
But if you dont have very good seeing most of the year, then maybe a smaller MAK would be a better choice!

Chas
Posted 08/01/2005 12:58AM #2
After reviewing that thread, particularly in light of some of Roland Christen’s and Gordon Dayton’s posts, I am reconsidering a larger MakCass (MK 91), possibly a MakNewt....

Roland Christen pointed out some downsides of the Truss Dob – necessity of frequent collimation, unprotected optics need cleaning & recoating.


-----

As much as I respect and admire Roland Christen, I think he went a bit overboard on this one.

I cannot say how often it is necessary to recollimate a truss DOB that has not been disassembled, but in general collimation is a simple straight forward procedure that most often consists of checking to be sure that the scope is still collimated. Most often it is.

And if it isn't, collimating it is a easily done. A few minutes should do it.

As far as recoating the mirrors, I would venture to guess that if care is taken to keep the scope covered when not in use, the mirror will stay clean.

In the end I think it comes down to this: Are you someone that likes a scope that is accessible and something that you can tinker with or do you want something that is a black box and needs to go back to the manufacturer when something is not quite right??

Jon
Posted 08/01/2005 01:27AM #3
I transport my Starmaster 11 ELT in two pieces: 1.the rocker box 2. the mirror box-and trusses and upper cage. Fits ito my Honda CRV with the seat put down. That way, it holds colllimation precisely and there is no setup and teardown.
In general I prefer premium Dobs to other designs.
Collimation is not difficult to learn and is easier on a Newtonian than on a Mak.
The new Starmster Versa series should hold collimation if not disassembled.
I don't like the cooldown issues people report with Maks but I have no personal experience with Maks.
I think you would be very happy with a 14.5 inch Starmaster or a 15 inch Obsession, or a 15 inch Plettstone. Give Rick Singmaster, at Starmaster a call, and give Michelle Stone at Plettstone Telescopes a call, and see what they advise, and then make up your mind. Ask them why it might make sense to buy their scope rather than an unspecified different one. They won't make negative comments about other manufacturers, by the way.
Hope this helps,
Bill Meyers
Posted 08/01/2005 02:05AM #4
For every large aperture Mak owner there are at least 10,000 Dob owners out there, so do not be surpised of the overwhelming recommendation to go with a Dobsonian.

Thanks,
Vahe
Posted 08/01/2005 02:12AM #5
Hi Gregg,

I have had a lot of scopes over the years. From 80mm to 20". My most used scope by a large amount is my 14.5" Starmaster. It does everything great. If I could only own one scope this would most likely be the one. I would get one if you can swing the money. You will never be disappointed with this scope.
Posted 08/01/2005 06:50PM #6
Greg,

In response to your question about exit pupil...

It may seem counterintuitive, but the longer focal length of the Mak will actually inhibit your ability to reach high magnification vs. a 14.5" dob in the f/4.5 range. The reason: the long f ratio gives such a small exit pupil that it is harder to reach high magnifications.

9" f13.5 Mak with 1mm exit pupil -> 13.5mm eyepiece -> ~228x

14.5" f4.5 Dob with 1mm exit pupil -> 4.5mm eyepiece -> ~368x

-David
Posted 08/01/2005 09:19PM | Edited 08/01/2005 09:20PM #7
You have a lot of good advice already. My $0.02.

> My primary interest is planetary (This could change
> with a larger dob). The MK91 has a 3100mm FL – allowing
> the use of longer FL EP’s. BUT – a 12” or 13” Dob will
> have a larger exit pupil. Which wins out?

The larger aperture wins. Under good seeing conditions, which you will have in Florida, the larger aperture will give higher resolution and more image detail. This is just basic physics.

> How long will it take to start viewing with a truss
> dob? I won’t be going to a dark site – just the yard.
> Do I need to collimate each time out?

With a little finesse, you would not need to wait very long to observe. Store it in unheated space, near evening temperature. If scope stays assembled, no, doesn't need to collimate often; every couple sessions.

> How often is recoating needed to maintain reasonably
> premium performance?

Again a little finesse helps. Try to avoid dew on the mirrors; dust it off with compressed air now and then. Maybe re-coat every 10 - 20 years. Just to put things in perspective, some high-end APOs I've owned have needed factory service far sooner than the Newts have needed re-coating.

> Premium dob owners – when viewing planets – do you
> use small FL EP’s, or do you Barlow / Powermate?

Both. I tend to like simple long Barlows (e.g. TV 3x). Besides the magnification, it gets the observer a bit farther from the light path.

> In the end - it all comes down to the views.
> Opinions? Which are better – with an emphasis on
> contrast. In my opinion – Jupiter is the real test.

At WSP in Florida Keys I have side-by-side compared my StarMaster 11 ELT against AP 10" Mak-Cass, 10" APO, and C14s on Jupiter and Saturn. It is close tie between these. The best views were similar, except the C14s were a little less crisp. Disadvantage of the StarMaster is that the performance depended a little on the wind direction -- if breeze was coming from behind the observer the view was a little less steady as observer heat plume went into the optical path. Mak-Cass and APO did not have this problem. On the other hand, when dew was bad, the Mak-Cass, APO, and C14 were quickly put out of action -- either shut down or very poor views, and the StarMaster was fine for a couple more hours.

> Has anyone seen / used the V-8?

Contact me off-line.