Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Obsession or Starmaster

Started by explore, 01/09/2004 01:30AM
Posted 01/09/2004 01:30AM Opening Post
I'm looking to upgrade to a large dob(probably 18"). I wanted to get your opinions on which brand you like better and why. Yes, I know you can't go wrong with either one, but the fact is each one has its advantages and disadvantages. I have never seen one of these scopes in person, only pictures.

Obsessions seem to have the high quality furniture look to them. Starmasters are no slouch, but they don't look quite as good as Obsession scopes. But I'm just going on the pictures I have seen of these scopes.

In terms of mirror, well I'm not sure that a Zambuto is really any better than a Torus(the mirror I would go with if I bought an Obsession). The thing that I like about Torus is they test each mirror and post the results on their website(with pictures of the test results). Still, Zambuto mirrors do have that cache about them.

I like the fact that Starmaster rigorously test each telescope(including the mirror) that it sells. I don't believe that Obsession does this. To me the testing that Starmaster does is a nice selling point.

Ok, bottom line, which brand would you choose? I would like to hear from people who have seen(and preferable used) these scopes in person. I know there are other brands of dobs to choose from out there, but I have narrowed it down to these two. And please, I don't want any of these types of responses: "Well, you can't go wrong with either one". You have to pick one or the other. Thanks!


Posted 01/09/2004 01:47AM #1
Call Rick Singmaster at Starmaster and talk for 30 minutes.
Call Dave K. at Obsession and talk for 30 minutes.
Go visit the Zambuto e-group board and read Carl Zambuto's posts.
Look at the relative resale values of Obsession vs. Starmaster.
There is more to a Zambuto mirror than reputation alone.
No one supports customers better than Starmaster.
Go to a star party and see these scopes in action.
DO a search here to find this topic covered several times over the last couple of years.

Good luck,
Doug
Posted 01/09/2004 01:50AM #2
Oohhh, a new can of worms! ;^) This is sure to generate some passionate debate.

Well, I am on my fourth Starmaster, so I want to admit my bias right up front.

The Obsession may look a bit better than the Starmaster, but they both look pretty darned good, IMHO. The Obsession is brown, the Starmaster is oak. A matter of preference, I suppose, but I like the look of my Starmaster better. Then again, I didn't buy it to be furniture.

The Obsession, IMHO, has smoother motions than the Starmaster. This can be a good or bad thing. I have seen Obsessions windmill in a breeze that the Starmaster laughed at.

I prefer the triangular configuration of the Starmaster's trusses, as they make it faster to set up.

I don't like the sling that the Obsession uses, as I have seen Obsession owners have to recollimate two or three times during the night. I have seldom had to recollimate during the night after my initial collimation. Also, on the subject of the mirror cell, I love the fact that I can remove my mirror and transport it separately in its own transport box. It makes the whole thing easier for those of us with back problems to own a larger scope. I recently had to help the owner of a 20" Obsession unload his scope out of a SUV and just about ruptured myself.

I like the thinner mirror, as it cools down much faster. Regardless of what the Obsession website says, the thinner mirrors in the Starmasters (D. Kriege does not mention Starmaster specifically) do NOT show astigmatism because the mirror is supported properly, the way the mirror maker supports it for testing.

I know that there has been much said about Carl Zambuto's testing methods, and his claims for Strehl and wavefront error, but I have now owned three CZ mirrors and can tell you that the proof of the pudding is in the eating. The deep sky views through my 14.5" Starmaster beat the views through any other telescope in my club, and on nights of good seeing, the planetary views do too. Having said that, if the Torus mirror is good, then I think that one would be splitting hairs to tell the difference in actual views at the eyepiece through either one. Once one gets into the area of premium optics, the views should be outstanding no matter who the mirror maker is.

I like the fact that Rick tests each scope throughly, under the night sky with eyepieces. He not only checks the mirror, but the goto/tracking system if it is ordered, and the whole scope for any flaws, etc.

Rick's customer service is second to none. I bought my first Starmaster from Rick six years ago, and I still get Christmas cards from him and his family. I can call him anytime at all, including weekends, to discuss anything from collimation to the weather.

Hope this helps!

Doug
Midway, FL
Posted 01/09/2004 12:59PM #3

I'm looking to upgrade to a large dob(probably 18"). I wanted to get your opinions on which brand you like better and why. Yes, I know you can't go wrong with either one, but the fact is each one has its advantages and disadvantages. I have never seen one of these scopes in person, only pictures.

Obsessions seem to have the high quality furniture look to them. Starmasters are no slouch, but they don't look quite as good as Obsession scopes. But I'm just going on the pictures I have seen of these scopes.

In terms of mirror, well I'm not sure that a Zambuto is really any better than a Torus(the mirror I would go with if I bought an Obsession). The thing that I like about Torus is they test each mirror and post the results on their website(with pictures of the test results). Still, Zambuto mirrors do have that cache about them.

I like the fact that Starmaster rigorously test each telescope(including the mirror) that it sells. I don't believe that Obsession does this. To me the testing that Starmaster does is a nice selling point.

Ok, bottom line, which brand would you choose? I would like to hear from people who have seen(and preferable used) these scopes in person. I know there are other brands of dobs to choose from out there, but I have narrowed it down to these two. And please, I don't want any of these types of responses: "Well, you can't go wrong with either one". You have to pick one or the other. Thanks!
*************************
You cant go wrong with a Starmaster! I have owned four Starmasters, and i have a new 11" ELT with GO-TO on order.

Every Starmaster arrived in perfect shape, and was easy to set up, the optics are the best bar none! I have used over 1100x on the planets, in super seeing with a 14.5" Starmaster. The GO-TO works like a charm, and is very easy to use. I just cant find one bad thing to say about Starmaster, and Rick is a pure joy to talk with, and will break his back to help you with any problem!

Chas P.


Posted 01/09/2004 02:23PM #4
I would love to have a house-full of oak furniture of the quality of Starmaster scopes :>).

Randy

Randy Roy
Posted 01/10/2004 02:35PM #5
Chris,

I bought a used StarMaster 12.5" ELT last year off A-Mart. Over the course of the year I have introduced myself to Rick through some email questions. He has been very gracious, answered my questions quickly, and made me feel like an original owner. From my perspective that is unbeatable customer service!

I also love the scope!

John