Image of the day

Captured by
Byron Davies

M-52, NGC-7635, SH2-157, SH2-158, SH2-159, SH2-161, NGC-7510

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Re: most knowledgeable

Started by Tom Mengel, 06/24/2005 10:42PM
Posted 06/24/2005 10:42PM Opening Post
This kind of “Beauty Pageant” is not a good thing in the long run. I think each person would bring his/her own area of knowledge to the table as a piece of the composite, and no one is better than the rest. All persons mentioned in your post are great in their own fields and one of the biggest thrills for me personally here on AM is to see what they have to say on any giver subject (even if the knowledge is "at odds" at times). I can truthfully say I’ve learned a tremendose amount from these folks over the time I’ve been reading their posts. I also firmly believe there is no "best" of the group for the above reason: the subject of equipment is just too broad.

And since everyone's mileage will always vary trying to pin one down one person as "king of the hill" will only result in more heat than light with no clear winner emerging. And the resulting flame wars might just drive a few aforementioned folks off the boards to all our collective loss.

Tom Mengel
Moderator Equipment Talk

“Insanity: Trying the same thing over and over and expecting different results”.
Albert Einstein
Posted 06/24/2005 11:12PM #1
Since i read alot of Rolands post, i would pick him as number one on optics!

I'm sure there are many other very smart optics and scope makers around.

I know just enough to get into trouble when it comes to optics, but Roland really knows his stuff!

Chas
Posted 06/25/2005 05:03PM #2
Well said Tom. We are fortunate to have all of those named. They are performing a labor of love. It is not a popularity contest. To attempt to pick a #1 top dog is insulting to all the rest.
Linton