Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Televue 16mm T5 question

Started by ivanong, 01/02/2005 04:55AM
Posted 01/02/2005 04:55AM Opening Post
Hi, I wear glasses to correct astigmatism. I see the specs on the Nagler 16mm T5 as having 10mm Eye Relief. Seems a tad short. Can anyone wearing glasses share some feedback? Is it worth getting this for the image quality when I cannot enjoy the wide field view? Are there other alternative recommendations in the 15-18mm range?
Many thanks for your help,
Ivan
Posted 01/02/2005 06:36AM #1
I will give another vote for the 17mm T-4. It has better eye relief and is a great EP as well.
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 01/02/2005 01:48PM #2
Hello Ivan
While the 17mm that the others suggest may be the way to go, I want to point something out. Depending on how bad and location of your astigmatism in your eye you may not need to wear glasses if the exit pupil gets small enough to miss the astigmatism in your eye. Oh course, this will depend on your scope.
Hope this helps
Buck
Posted 01/02/2005 06:30PM #3
While not exactly in the range you mentioned, you might try a 14mm Pentax XW or used XL. They both have 20mm ER and are very comfortable to use.
Posted 01/02/2005 08:05PM #4


I know there is a lot of support for the Nagler 17 T4. A lot of people love this eyepiece, but I don't think it is nearly as good as the 16 T5. If you wear glasses and must have a 2" eyepiece, than fine get the 17 T4. If you want the best wide field eyepiece in this range than get the 16 T5. When the 16 T5 first came out 3 of us got together and did a very in depth test of these two eyepieces. We went into it with the idea that the 17 T4 was going to kill it, but. The 16 T5 had better on and off axis sharpness, contrast, field flatness, and light transmission. The 17 T5 had better eye relief and chromatic aberration. One of the testers liked the 16 T5 so much he sold his 17 T4 to get one. Also the 16 T5 will binoview and good luck doing that with the 17.