Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Meade 8.8mm UW smooth side vs. eyecup version

Started by proteus, 09/10/2007 12:47PM
Posted 09/10/2007 12:47PM | Edited 09/10/2007 01:15PM Opening Post
I recently had the pleasure to help a couple fellow Amarters through a problem with their Meade 4000 8.8mm UW eps. I won't go into details but if you do some sleuthing through the threads you can probably figure it out. One ep was the eyecup version and the other a smooth side (flat top) version.

I have one observation as to why Meade (Japanese) maybe changed the design of the smooth side version to the eyecup version. First, optically they are the same. The lenses are the same and the spacing of the elements is the same. So to those thinking one is better than the other this perception is only aesthetics. From an assemblers point of view however, one is definitely better than the other.

Keeping optics clean during assembly is time consuming. Even in the best conditions with the right tools an assembler has to fight with cue tip lint, micro specks from hell, solvent residue, etc. Maybe you don't see a speck on the lens before placing it in the housing, but add the next lens to the stack and the magnification of that element makes the contaminate visible. Let's not forget the micron sized coating specks that become visible during the stacking process. Is it a contaminate or is it a coating speck? Do you lift the lens back out to find out?

This is where the assemblers probably helped with the second design of the above eps and the others of the same series.

With the smooth side version you have to drop the lenses into the housing. With the eyecup version, you can stack the lenses and then place the housing over the stack. I can appreciate this second design for making the build easier. There's way less risk of edge chipping of the optical elements in the second design.

Amongst the lens elements in the stack the 8.8 has a singlet with really sharp edges. Cant or tip this element slightly in the housing and you risk chipping it. Also, removing the elements from the smooth side version is difficult. You either have to push them out with your FINGER COT covered finger from the eye side of the housing, or use pretty good vacuum and a probe to lift the heavy doublets out.

Now I understand why no one in their right mind would want to clean or repair eps for a living/hobby. One, the lenses aren't available to replace those that are scratched or damaged. Second, the ep up for cleaning may have been attempted by the user. Finger oils and such are a nightmare to remove. Also the lens stack may be altered and who knows how it went together without a drawing or sample?

So if you see specks inside your ep, it's probably coating specks as many manufacturers will disclaim with their supplied documentation. I've seen this disclaimer with some of my new eps.

So unless you see a big goober inside your ep or it's contaminated inside by liquid, then please stick to cleaning the two outside surfaces and call it good.

I made a hand sketch of the lens stack. I plan on drawing it up in CAD. When I get to that I'll make it available here. Joe

Posted 09/10/2007 01:05PM #1
Interesting post...I have one of the units with the eyecup (great eyepiece, by the way) and have always wondered why the smooth side one was always sought after. Nice to know I'm not missing some mysterious missing ingredient.

Hank
Posted 09/11/2007 03:34AM #2
Thanks for the info Joe....
Posted 09/11/2007 06:30AM #3
Thanks for the heads up Joe, I know you are experienced in these matters. wink

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 09/11/2007 10:59PM #4
Let me suggest you just scan and post the "hand drawing."
Posted 09/12/2007 03:05PM #5
Would like some help in deciding what filter (2" in this case) would accentuate differert type of Nebula objects? My only experience using a filter was that it was too "dark"... thanks for your insight, JM

Posted 09/19/2007 01:58AM #6
As former owner of a smoothside version, I want to add that the eyecup provides a great deal of protection, whereas the eye lens of the smoothside is right at the surface and very exposed.

Otherwise, it was a pleasure to use and performed wonderfully.

Jim