Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Widefields: Are They Worth It?

Started by Rod Kaufman, 01/13/2010 02:28AM
Posted 01/13/2010 02:28AM Opening Post
Given all the hype about 100 degree eyepieces eclipsing 82 degree models and dwarfing everything else, I've still have to ask: are they worth it?
Here's why: I've come to the conclusion, as at least one other amateur that I've read on a google search has, that there is no way you can take in and see a 100 degree field of view at once. There is no way you can take in and see a 82 degree field of view at once. You can look at a portion of these fields, such as the top, bottom, sides or center of the field of view but there is no way you can comprehend all of it at once. It is evident to me that about 70 degrees or so is near maximum of what you can reasonably see at once and comprehend what you're seeing. Even then, if you're looking for a small planetary or galaxy, you're still going to have to view portions of the field in order to realize what you've seen before you identify the object.
So I ask, are widefields really worth it?
Posted 01/13/2010 02:48AM #1
Obviously, many people think so and have spoken with their wallet. The real question is whether you like such fields and the need to look around. Only you can decide if they are a good fit for you.

One real advantage of the larger apparent field is the ability to see the same true field as a longer focal length eyepiece at a higher power. Added magnification benefits many deep sky objects, and the wider true field allows "framing" more objects.

Clear skies, Alan
Posted 01/13/2010 03:50AM | Edited 01/13/2010 03:51AM #2
Rod
I was impressed with the 8mm I looked through and like the extra FOV, even if you cannot take it all in at once. It is like standing on a mountain vista without a restricted FOV. No you cannot focus on it all at once, but the Vista is necessary. So the 8mm got a two thumbs up for me. Would I buy one? Now that's a different story. If it weren't for trying to maintain domestic tranquility, I would probably have three and a 20" dob. For now I will stick with my 20, 17 13, 11, and 9 Naglers.

Jud

I Yam What I Yam!
Posted 01/13/2010 03:56AM #3
Hi °Rod,
The great thing about all those that are upgrading to the 100° EPs is that you can get a better deal on the 82° Naglers. I think that we will see a lot more of them at fair prices in the next year.

You can see about 90° without having to look around a lot, but even a Nagler you have to look around. The 100° are great, but I just have a hard time justifying the cost.

My $.02. smile

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 01/13/2010 07:14PM #4
I like a clean crisp FOV without a lot of seagulls, fuzzballs or fireworks at the edge. I also like wide field viewing more than high power stuff. I have looked through the Ethos and was impressed but not enough to part with the funds to buy two or three and owning only one does not make sense.

I really like the views thorugh my 24Pan and 13mm and 9mm Naglers. I also have a 17mm Nagler that I have yet to put in a scope. So far this collection has probably cost me about $150/hr of viewing. Hopefully that will decrease in the near future.

I have always been content once the field stop is out of my view. I simply can't justify ever buying an Ethos given the skies around here and the time I can dedicate to viewing.

dan
Posted 01/14/2010 01:40PM #5
Rod,

What is "worth" has a lot to do with this question.

The Ethos, etc. provide a superior view. That is surely nice to use for most of us.

If I had to choose between it and a new sport coat and slacks, I'd go with the Ethos. If I had to choose between it and meals for my family for a month, I'd go with the meals.

Financial means radically change the definition of "worth."

Alex
Posted 01/15/2010 05:55AM | Edited 01/15/2010 06:01AM #6
I don't know. The 13mm Ethos is my favorite eyepiece of all time, out of a few hundreds by the time I lost count. But I have to admit that it's a good focal length for my scope (2mm exit pupil).

The "take it in" argument is based on an entirely personal premise--that the wider field has no value if you can't soak it all in while staring at the center of the field. I reject that premise completely. Limiting yourself to staring down the center of the view with a widefield, not rolling the eye, is a waste. Sure, if that's the way you observe, don't buy the widefield, but it sounds weird to me. I think of it this way. I'm going to want to roll my eyeball a little bit, and what's the AFoV that represents the size peripheral field I'd like to maintain at all times? I argue that it's about 50 degrees, i.e. 25 degrees of peripheral field in all directions. Now to get this with a Plossl, I do have to stare straight down the center because if I roll my eye to the side, the peripheral field drops below 25 degrees to one side. If I go to a 60 degree eyepiece, I can roll my eye around the central 10 degrees and maintain a Plossl-size peripheral field. If a 70 degree eyepiece, I can use the central 20 degrees for direct vision. If an 82 degree eyepiece, the central 32 degrees can be used. Now with a 100 degree eyepiece, I can look anywhere in the central 50 degrees and maintain at least 50 degrees of peripheral field, i.e. at least 25 degrees in every direction. That sounds perfect to me.

Attached Image:

mhosea's attachment for post 135069
Posted 01/15/2010 04:07PM #7
The obvious answer IMO is that for it to be "worth it" is completely subjective and depends entirely on the perceptions and feelings of the person.

Specifically for me it is not worth it on several levels (and yes I have viewed thru them).
- - only 1 22% increase in angular size from an 82 deg Ep so simply not significant enough perceptually for me and I much prefer the percent increase to be around 40% (for comparison, going Plossl to Nagler is a 64% jump and dramatic).
- - Size and bulk of current implementations is simply too bulky and user unfriendly for me. If they ever get them down to the T6 sizing then perhaps.
- - Cost is too high. For the 22% angular gain I personally don't feel the 220% gain in price (or thereabouts) acceptable for me.
- - Any slight background darkness and magnitude depth improvement from the small change in exit pupil / magnification I may get replacing an existing 82 with a shorter FL 100 deg is too small of a visual gain considering all other factors.
- - Any additional TFOV I can get from the 100 deg over the 82 deg I can as effectively obtain by just using a slightly longer FL. A 16T5 and 13E have about the same FS, a 3mm difference in FL is not a deal breaker in any view with any of my scopes.

Again though, all these are unique to me (and perhaps others). There are plenty of people for whom small incremental changes are significant things which they enjoy. Nothing wrong with that. Plenty of play room for everyone as long as new lines get added and not at the expense of other lines.
Posted 01/15/2010 09:44PM #8
I have a lot of ep's but as far as what gets used, I'm pretty much down to two: a 13mm ethos and a 22mm T4 Nagler. I might seil some of my naglers and spring for a higher power ethos for planetary especially with Mars on its way. At the other end, for me,the price tag on the 21mm ethos put it alongside the element: unobtanium.