Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Argo Navis and Sky Commander comparison

Started by lintonius, 02/12/2007 04:36AM
Posted 02/12/2007 04:36AM | Edited 02/12/2007 04:37AM Opening Post
OK. New thread. Sounds good.
I'm preparing to hook up a ServoCat system on my 14.5" dob.
I'm going to operate it with my existing Sky Commander for the time being, per Gary's recommendation.
But I may upgrade to an Argo Navis at some time in the future.
I have played around with Floyd's a bit, and it does seem rather intuitive to use.
John is suggesting that the SkyCom is less accurate,
but over the course of an evening, I find 95% of objects in the FOV of the eyepiece.
Occasionally, one will be just outside field, and I will find it in a couple seconds,
usually by glancing through my optical finder.
So, while I'm not trying to detract from the AN,
how much more accurate do you need to be?
Linton
Posted 02/12/2007 05:37AM #1
Hi Linton,
As you know I have a Sky Commander too and in fact have had four of them. Never found them to be anything but quite accurate and easy to use.
You got to play with my Argo Navis and so you know what it is like and how it works as far as accuracy is concerned.
I think that most accuracy problems are in the scope and not the DSC unit. Either the encoders, encoder mounting or imperfections in the mount itself as the common causes I believe. Also connections and battery condition are other major factors.

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 02/12/2007 06:22PM #2
FWIW, I've been using the Sky Commander and SkyTracker setup that comes with Starmasters for around 6 years now, and it works fine. However, one thing I'd really like to have that the ServoCat/AN combination has is the spiral search feature. Many time with my scopes, it does the GOTO, but the object is for whatever reason just outside the FOV. But where, and how far? I find myself doing this thing all the time where I do an awkward "manual" spiral search, looking around in the general proximity of the original FOV via the control box until it pops into view. It would be nice to have the scope doing this, so I could just watch, and when I see it, I could just hit a button, it would stop, and it would track from there. In the overall scheme of things though, this is minor for me.