Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

F 6 or F4.5

Started by scottw, 05/23/2011 05:53PM
Posted 05/23/2011 05:53PM Opening Post
Does either one, an F5 or F4.5 require coma correction for general visual observations? I htink I read where the F4.5 might require it.

Thanks for the input.

Scott
Posted 05/23/2011 10:15PM #1
Scott,
The requirement for coma correction can be a personal choice. At F4.5, coma will probably be at least noticable at the outer field of view, but the decision of whether or not it needs correction will vary between users. It may not bother you as much as others. At F4.5, though I have a Parracor Coma Corrector, I seldom put it in the focuser. Others are religous about it's necessity. At F6, chances are you won't need it unless you are severely bothered by the presence of coma. We are all different, thank goodness !!!
YMMV
Brad

Posted 05/24/2011 10:10AM #2
Scott Anderson said:

Does either one, an F5 or F4.5 require coma correction for general visual observations? I htink I read where the F4.5 might require it.

Thanks for the input.

Scott

Scott:

In some sense, coma correction is a personal choice and it also depends on whether you are using eyepieces that are corrected for off-axis astigmatism at these fast focal ratios. If your eyepieces are otherwise sharp to the edge at F/4.5 or F/5, then a Paracorr can take the views to the next level, clean stars right up to the edge....

I have a small collection of Newtonians F/4-F/5 ranging in aperture from 130mm to over 600mm. I just about always use a Paracorr with a set of Naglers. Adding the Paracorr makes a noticeable improvement.

At the low powers, you can see the coma as the tails on off-axis stars, they are ignorable if the stars aren't bright, the Paracorr cleans this right up...

At high powers, without the Paracorr, those comatic tails are visible but one also has to be concerned with the effect of the coma on planetary views, the sweet spot is very small.
The diffraction limited region of a fast parabolic mirror is surprisingly small... 2.75mm at F/5, 2.0mm at F/4.5. In a 15 inch scope, these corresponds to a true field of view of 5 arcminutes at F/5, 4 arcminutes at F/4.5.

At 200X, these are apparent fields of view, the size of the "sweet spot", of about 16 degrees at F/5, 13 degrees at F/4.5. A Paracorr increases these by a factor of 6x...

So, in a sense, coma correction is an individual choice but if one wants to get the best possible views, correcting the coma is essential. Newtonians can provide quite wonderful "refractor-like" views with the combination of the good eyepieces and a Paracorr.

Jon