I am considering the Starmaster 16" for sale in the classifieds. I know that specs dont tell all, but Id like to get feedback on those posted on this Zambuto mirror.The Strehl is .98 which I know is excellent. The RTA is 0.63. P-V is 16.3. RMS is 44. Thanks for any comments from you experts out there.
Zambuto mirror-please rate.
Started by dru, 12/06/2009 02:02AM
Posted 12/06/2009 02:02AM
Opening Post
Posted 12/06/2009 04:33AM
| Edited 12/06/2009 04:45AM
#1
The numbers, if correct, imply a superb mirror. The key
issue, at least in my opinion, is that the numbers are
often incorrect. Zambuto derives the numbers from the Foucault
test, which assumes the mirror is rotationally symmetric
about the center. Non-symmetric errors like astigmatism
are not reliably measured by this test. It can be argued that
a well-trained tester can spot astigmatism visually on the
Foucault test stand, or by Ronchi tests, or by testing at the
center of curvature with an eyepiece, but none of these are
going to show up in the Foucault numbers. I've got a very nice
16" mirror (not from Zambuto) that is 0.999 Strehl by Foucault,
but star testing in a scope shows it has bad astigmatism and
Strehl around 0.5. I believe it is due to these types of
issues that Zambuto has ceased to issue the test reports. It is
nice to have the piece of paper showing excellent optics, but
realistically these reports are probably not very accurate.
This having been said, Zambuto does make very fine mirrors.
I have the same StarMaster 16" model, and the optics are excellent.
It is not perfect -- it does have some weak zones in it I can see
in careful star tests -- but nothing like the horrible problems
I have seen from some other mirror makers.
I would advise to forget about the numbers (they are misleading
if not wrong) and just go on the good reputation of Zambuto.
The most accurate and best test you can do, will be to buy the
scope and do your own star tests on it. This will be much more
accurate than Foucault, Ronchi, interferometry, etc. If there is
some bad problem, which would be very unlikely, I am confident
Zambuto would stand behind it and fix it.
Here's a nice Saturn I took couple years back in the SM16/Zambuto.
The optics are pretty good.
issue, at least in my opinion, is that the numbers are
often incorrect. Zambuto derives the numbers from the Foucault
test, which assumes the mirror is rotationally symmetric
about the center. Non-symmetric errors like astigmatism
are not reliably measured by this test. It can be argued that
a well-trained tester can spot astigmatism visually on the
Foucault test stand, or by Ronchi tests, or by testing at the
center of curvature with an eyepiece, but none of these are
going to show up in the Foucault numbers. I've got a very nice
16" mirror (not from Zambuto) that is 0.999 Strehl by Foucault,
but star testing in a scope shows it has bad astigmatism and
Strehl around 0.5. I believe it is due to these types of
issues that Zambuto has ceased to issue the test reports. It is
nice to have the piece of paper showing excellent optics, but
realistically these reports are probably not very accurate.
This having been said, Zambuto does make very fine mirrors.
I have the same StarMaster 16" model, and the optics are excellent.
It is not perfect -- it does have some weak zones in it I can see
in careful star tests -- but nothing like the horrible problems
I have seen from some other mirror makers.
I would advise to forget about the numbers (they are misleading
if not wrong) and just go on the good reputation of Zambuto.
The most accurate and best test you can do, will be to buy the
scope and do your own star tests on it. This will be much more
accurate than Foucault, Ronchi, interferometry, etc. If there is
some bad problem, which would be very unlikely, I am confident
Zambuto would stand behind it and fix it.
Here's a nice Saturn I took couple years back in the SM16/Zambuto.
The optics are pretty good.
Attached Image:
Posted 12/06/2009 05:22AM
#2
I lack the experience of some of these guys, but I have a 10" f/6 Zambuto, supposedly Strehl 0.96, in one of the original Starmaster ELs, and it just smokes. If Carl ever made a bad mirror, Rick sent it back! My scope was delayed for weeks until Rick could test it on a good night. If the seeing is good enough to star test a 10", fooey, I am going to look at stuff.
Ron
Ron
Posted 12/06/2009 06:32AM
#3
Hi Andrew.
Rest assured, Carl Zambuto consistently produces some of the finest mirrors available.
About four years ago I too, sought similar advice here.
Long story short: I bought a 14.5" f/4.3 Starmaster and I've been very happy ever since.
I added a 10" f/6 a little later and it's great too.
I'd say jump on the opportunity!
Linton
Rest assured, Carl Zambuto consistently produces some of the finest mirrors available.
About four years ago I too, sought similar advice here.
Long story short: I bought a 14.5" f/4.3 Starmaster and I've been very happy ever since.
I added a 10" f/6 a little later and it's great too.
I'd say jump on the opportunity!
Linton
Posted 12/06/2009 03:20PM
#4
Andrew Gawel said:
I am considering the Starmaster 16" for sale in the classifieds. I know that specs dont tell all, but Id like to get feedback on those posted on this Zambuto mirror.The Strehl is .98 which I know is excellent. The RTA is 0.63. P-V is 16.3. RMS is 44. Thanks for any comments from you experts out there.
Only way to rate any mirror is to get out under sky one a 9+ nite of seeing and see how it does on the planets or DSO's.
I never go by numbers. I can tell a super mirror from a so so mirror in less than a min on jupiter or saturn in 9+ skies.
I have owned 5 Zambutos and all of them could take 1000x+ with ease in my Florida seeing.
Chas
Funding Member