Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

AP 155 EDF vs TOA 150

Started by rag_alabama, 08/23/2009 03:34PM
Posted 08/23/2009 03:34PM | Edited 08/23/2009 06:29PM Opening Post
I have a wonderful but perplexing choice, a new Takahashi TOAS 150 or a 2000-2001 vintage AP 155 Starfire EDF. They are price equivalent. Any thoughts? I will be using a Losmandy HGM Titan/Gemini or AP900GTO mount regardless of OTA (any thoughts on the mount as well). This will be a major step up for my equipment smile .

Thanks,
Robert
Posted 08/27/2009 03:45AM #1
AP 900 and Tak TOA 150. Matter of fact Herb is offering a deal on that exact combo now!

Chris
Posted 08/27/2009 10:06AM #2
This is a no brainer, AP 155. Both will have a similar view but the AP will retain its value. Martin

"In the beginner's mind there are many possibilities, but in the expert's there are few." Shunryu Suzuki[COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR]
Posted 08/27/2009 07:05PM | Edited 08/27/2009 07:06PM #3
Robert Gilbert said:

I have a wonderful but perplexing choice, a new Takahashi TOAS 150 or a 2000-2001 vintage AP 155 Starfire EDF. They are price equivalent. Any thoughts? I will be using a Losmandy HGM Titan/Gemini or AP900GTO mount regardless of OTA (any thoughts on the mount as well). This will be a major step up for my equipment smile .

Thanks,
Robert

Others will likely disagree but . . .

It all depends on configuration I suppose. Just clarifiying thatt is the 155 an EDF (4 inch focuser with flattener) or EDFS (2.7 inch focuser without flattener). Does it have a Starlight FeatherTouch pinion?

1) the 155EDF is significantly lighter than the TOA150.

2) the Starfire has thinner lens elements and a smaller lens cell. It cools down a fair bit quicker even though it is oil spaced. It doesn't require a tube counterbalance.

3) the Tak micro-focus or whatever it is called is not even close to the Feathertouch. I used one for a month or three on my Sky90 but when Starlight Instruments made the replacement pinion (I was one of the people begging and pleading), the Tak micro-whatever was GONE.

4) overall I find the AP focuser body to be sturdier than the Tak. I mean both the 2.7 and 4 inch AP focusers.

5) No contest for me. I'd take the AP155 - but I am biased.

Rick.
Posted 08/27/2009 07:42PM | Edited 08/27/2009 08:14PM #4
My impression from the Ronchi and knife-edge tests at
http://homepage3.nifty.com/cz_telesco/refracter_test.htm
is that the TOA has slightly better color correction -- patterns are
more color-free. TOA150:
http://homepage3.nifty.com/cz_telesco/toa150ronkitest.JPG
AP155:
http://homepage3.nifty.com/cz_telesco/AP155EDF.JPG
But you would probably not notice the difference unless
you are obsessive about such things. They are both fine scopes.
You are very lucky to have such a choice!
Posted 08/27/2009 10:43PM #5
Thanks to all. I got the AP 155 EDF with a MI-250 mount/ATS portable pier grin .