Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Bosch or Dewalt??

Started by web0178230, 11/25/2005 03:56PM
Posted 11/25/2005 03:56PM Opening Post
[COLOR="Purple"]I'm thinking of asking "Santa" for a new router for Christmas. My 25 year old Sears model is just not up to the job any more. Sooo...I'm eyeing the Bosch and Dewalt fixed + plunge base kits. Anyone have any comments, good or bad, about these tools? My use is certainly not heavy duty but I'd like something that will stand up to occasionally cutting upper cage rings from 3/4" plywood. Should I get the more powerful model or would the lower powered version do okay?
Thanks for your thoughts!
Bill[/COLOR]
Posted 11/25/2005 05:15PM #1
Bosch is used more often in cabinet shops, IMO; De Walt has more of a rep as high-end hobbyist stuff, though their human engineering features are good.

In practice either will probably serve you well.

J Adams
Posted 11/26/2005 12:16AM #2
[COLOR="Purple"]Thanks for all of the feedback!

The Craftsman router was a gift from my wife many years ago. It doesn't get used much any more so I thought I's upgrade as I start my latest ATM project. From what I can gather, the Bosch and DeWalts are usually ranked fairly high in reviews, hence my interest in those models.

I really only seem to use a router a couple of times each year so I don't need a super-heavy-duty-production model. Thus my interest in maybe getting by with the 1.75HP units vs the 2HP or 2.25HP units.

My Craftsman is a fixed base and I really need a plunge router...thus the fixed/plunge combos seem like good thing. Either the DeWalt or Bosch kits can be found for about $200.00 + shipping, which seems to be a pretty fair price for decent routers.

I was just curious if anyone had strong feelings about those brands/models.
Thanks!
Bill[/COLOR]
Posted 11/30/2005 02:21AM | Edited 11/30/2005 02:30AM #3
Bill,
I own about 15 routers and most of them are Porter-Cable, but I do have one older Bosch and it is pretty good too. I did buy a combo fixed/plunge set once, and regreted it. I don't like converting back and forth. If you sometimes need a plunger, just buy a plunge router.
I'm not a big Dewalt fan, but they do make a couple nice plunge routers. Dewalt does have a good engineering dept.
Linton
Posted 11/30/2005 02:47PM #4
Hi Bill,

Well, I haven't used the DeWalt so I can't compare, but I'm delighted with the Bosch combo unit.

FWIW, I asked about it on a couple of woodworking forums, and the consensus was pretty solidly in favor of the Bosch, with most of the dissenters favoring the Porter Cable. The attraction of the Porter Cable seemed to be mostly about availability of accessories, however.

Are you going to build a router table?

Mike