I am new to my new found hobby, and I have been doing a lot of researching. There is such a variety of eps when you put all the mm on paper it adds up to more confusion. I do realize the Barlow helps when you are on a budget and only have a few eps. My question is when a Barlow is used even a orion shorty not the plus. Will it depreciate the quality of your field of view ? Please share your thoughts I am very interested in hearing them. Thanks
Barlows Are They Worth It ?
Started by Dimpa, 03/11/2006 10:13AM
Posted 03/11/2006 10:13AM
Opening Post
Posted 03/11/2006 01:54PM
#1
Albert:
A decent barlow belongs in every eyepiece case, that's my opinion. A 2x barlow not only doubles the magnification but it can also help simple eyepieces cope with fast focal ratio scopes.
Over the years I have collected several barlows, including two Celestron Shortys and a Celestron Ultima, these are essentially the same as the Orion Shorty and Shorty Plus.
My normal choice is the Standard Shorty, it seems to do as good a job as the Ultima but with slightly less magnification, the Ultima is a 2.2x barlow. The Shorty is also easier to clean...
Jon
A decent barlow belongs in every eyepiece case, that's my opinion. A 2x barlow not only doubles the magnification but it can also help simple eyepieces cope with fast focal ratio scopes.
Over the years I have collected several barlows, including two Celestron Shortys and a Celestron Ultima, these are essentially the same as the Orion Shorty and Shorty Plus.
My normal choice is the Standard Shorty, it seems to do as good a job as the Ultima but with slightly less magnification, the Ultima is a 2.2x barlow. The Shorty is also easier to clean...
Jon
Posted 03/11/2006 02:43PM
#2
I'll disagree with the folks who say a barlow won't degrade image quality.
When you add a barlow to the optical path, you're adding more elements, and more glass to air surfaces. This will have an impact on contrast.
About the only time I use a barlow is if seeing conditions are good enough to go with higher power than my shortest eyepiece, or for more magnification when imaging.
Folks who need or like more eye relief will like them too, although eyepiece makers are starting to design shorter eyepieces with more eye relief.
But when your eyepiece choices are limited, a barlow will give you more options.
When you add a barlow to the optical path, you're adding more elements, and more glass to air surfaces. This will have an impact on contrast.
About the only time I use a barlow is if seeing conditions are good enough to go with higher power than my shortest eyepiece, or for more magnification when imaging.
Folks who need or like more eye relief will like them too, although eyepiece makers are starting to design shorter eyepieces with more eye relief.
But when your eyepiece choices are limited, a barlow will give you more options.
Posted 03/12/2006 02:25AM
#3
My thoughts are that one should get a decent 2x barlow. Do not shop price. If on a budget, then pick a mid priced(retail) unit. But purchase it used in the classifieds here. It's what they are for. One then gets a good optical quality barlow, instead of just functional. But for a budget price.
Funding Member