Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

If M42 is green, is this with a filter?

Started by fblue, 02/24/2006 10:53PM
Posted 02/24/2006 10:53PM Opening Post
I once again ask this question. Is the color seen with or without a filter?

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 02/24/2006 11:29PM #1
I see a faint green tinge with no filter (12.5" Royce mirror)...

Pat
Posted 02/24/2006 11:44PM | Edited 02/24/2006 11:44PM #2
Floyd Blue said:

I once again ask this question. Is the color seen with or without a filter?

Hi Floyd:

When I was 22, M42 was decidedly the palest green in my 10" Newtonian without any filter. I read about O III emission lines long after my eyes had seen the light green shade, so I know that I was not just seeing what I expected to see.

Now, 22 years later, I see no green. sad

Jim
Posted 02/25/2006 12:45AM #3
Definitely without. When I was seeing green in M42 in the late 70s and early 80s, modern sorts of nebula filters weren't out. In fact I have, somewhere, the issue of S&T in which the then brand-new "light pollution filters" were written about.

Jim's experience below may be prophetic about what I can expect when I get a peek at it again in something bigger than binos. I definitely saw it in a 6" in my early teens, but at 42 it may be a different story.
Posted 02/25/2006 01:37PM #4
Checked again last night. The nebula was a strange gray, but could not say I saw green. With UHC of course it is green and with greater detail with sharper but fainter stars.

I Yam What I Yam!
Posted 02/25/2006 10:28PM #5
I just drove in from Anza Borrego where I spent the night with the coyotes under a beautiful desert sky. Had M42 in my 15x70 Oberwerks, 102ED and 8" newt. It's definitely green in each view regardless of magnification for me. I don't see this in any other bright nebulosity or galaxy tho.

Jerry
Posted 02/25/2006 10:38PM #6
Humm, this is interesting. I'm in the latter half of 50's and just started in this hobby about 3 1/2 years ago and in every scope I've owned M42 has always been greenish. The darker the site the greener it is. Yet, in my binoculars it is more gray.
I've never paid much attention to the color variation, so what does all this mean? Is it the person? The equipment? The location? The seeing?
Dang if I know
Buck
Posted 02/27/2006 12:34AM | Edited 02/27/2006 12:37AM #7
Folks,
try M42 before you are fully dark adapted. Green is most apparent for me before my eyes have done the complete switch over. As I become more dark adapted the green fades. Sometimes replaced by other colors, sometimes not.

The green as I remember is actually an illusion. Like green components in double stars.
Posted 04/02/2006 03:08AM #8
When I saw M42 for the first time a few months ago, it was definitely a pale green, with no filter. It was beautiful!
Posted 04/02/2006 05:27PM #9
Floyd Blue said:

I once again ask this question. Is the color seen with or without a filter?

One night, many years ago, I was up at our club's observing site in Sanders Preserve, which is about 7 miles outside Schenectady, NY. Even then Schenectady had a pretty good light dome. I was observing Saturn with my 10" f/9.5. We noticed the fog had rolled in down in the Mohawk Valley, greatly reducing the effect of the city lights and darkening the sky.

I turned my scope toward M42, and it was amazing how vividly green it looked.

Clear skies, Alan