Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Heart and Soul Nebulas

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Ultravids vs. Duovids vs. Swar. ELs

Started by dwalton, 02/21/2005 02:11PM
Posted 02/21/2005 02:11PM | Edited 02/21/2005 02:29PM Opening Post
I've got a very, very nice pair of Pentax DCF SP 10x50's.

I'm wondering how much nicer one of the three binos listed above might be (in the 8x42 range - I may move away from 10x50's into something with a wider FOV and a bit more stability).

Are the Duovids as sharp/contrasty as the Ultravids? (The 8x-12x feature might be kinda nice to have.) How do the Swarovski 8.5x42's compare to both of them? I'm interested in personal experience/opinions, and I'm mainly looking at contrast/sharpness/edges, since I'm assuming that CA and color are reasonable in all of them. I live pretty far from any kind of store where I could go and try them out, so educated opinions and anectdotal info ends up being quite useful.

PS: I did do a comparo between my Pentax DCF SPs and the Swarovskis maybe two years ago, and despite the difference in magnification/FOV I wasn't able to justify the difference in cost, even though there was improvement and lust with the Swarovskis. I might be able to swing it now. :-)

Thanks,
Doug
Posted 02/22/2005 02:37AM #1
I wish I could comment directly on your other choices, but alas, I can only comment on the Swarovski binoculars. I have been using a pair of 10x42 EL's and they are SUPERB!!!!! I have done side by side comparisons with many of my coworker's high quality binos and I have never seen anything as good. They especially shine when conditions are not ideal. One other thing I have noticed is that the color fidelity is just amazing with my EL's. I actually notice the color problems in other binos now, where before I only noticed the differences in sharpness and clarity. I can't recommend the Swarovskis highly enough. I guarantee you would be happy with either the 10x42 or 8x42 EL's. It just doesn't get any better. (my 2-cents worth)

Cheers,
Tyler

PS - They are lightweight too!


"The expression of the beautiful is in direct ratio to the power of perception acquired by the artist." (Gustave Courbet)