Hi all -
This is the result of a couple of hours spent during the Academy Awards comparing the small stable of webcams I have collected over the past month or two. Because of the wide range of variables (including a different software driver for each camera) I didn't attempt a scientific study - rather I tried to see how closely I could get each to perform rendering the same scene - dimly lit, but with no turbulence to contend with. So I used as little gain as possible and let the shutter make up the difference. It would have been more meaningful to set the same shutter and vary the gain but on my Mac the shutter speed is referenced in a different way in each driver, it is impossible to set each camera the same.
In the end I was surprised to find the images so similar. The ToUcam is certainly slower than the B&W firewire cameras, and somewhat more noisy and contrasty - but it remains a fine performer. The new DMK 21BF04 seemed to produce the smoothest image and be capable of the fastest shutter setting. After stacking 20 frames, the detail in the DMK and the ToUcam were virtually identical - The Unibrain camera lagged behind slightly.
There are obvious advantages to recording at 30fps with a monochrome CCD for a high resoultion image. But I believe atmospheric conditions will be by far the deciding factor in the level of detail you will be able to capture.
Hopefully clear skies and warmer temperatures will let me offer some more meaningful comparisons in the coming months.
Alan
This is the result of a couple of hours spent during the Academy Awards comparing the small stable of webcams I have collected over the past month or two. Because of the wide range of variables (including a different software driver for each camera) I didn't attempt a scientific study - rather I tried to see how closely I could get each to perform rendering the same scene - dimly lit, but with no turbulence to contend with. So I used as little gain as possible and let the shutter make up the difference. It would have been more meaningful to set the same shutter and vary the gain but on my Mac the shutter speed is referenced in a different way in each driver, it is impossible to set each camera the same.
In the end I was surprised to find the images so similar. The ToUcam is certainly slower than the B&W firewire cameras, and somewhat more noisy and contrasty - but it remains a fine performer. The new DMK 21BF04 seemed to produce the smoothest image and be capable of the fastest shutter setting. After stacking 20 frames, the detail in the DMK and the ToUcam were virtually identical - The Unibrain camera lagged behind slightly.
There are obvious advantages to recording at 30fps with a monochrome CCD for a high resoultion image. But I believe atmospheric conditions will be by far the deciding factor in the level of detail you will be able to capture.
Hopefully clear skies and warmer temperatures will let me offer some more meaningful comparisons in the coming months.
Alan
Attached Image:
Alan Friedman
http://www.avertedimagination.com