Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Finding focus with a Newt

Started by [email protected], 05/10/2009 12:13PM
Posted 05/10/2009 12:13PM Opening Post
Hi all -- Finding afocal focus with refractors seems to be fairly straightforward but with Newtonian scopes, not so easy. I don't want to tackle moving the primary mirror forward to achieve focus. The only thing I've found so far is shooting thru a Klee barlow (2.8x) which of course increases the effective focal length of the scope and narrows the field of view. Are there any other solutions for afocal work?
Thanks for any help.

Bob Polcyn
Posted 05/16/2009 02:22AM | Edited 05/16/2009 02:24AM #1
Under afocal imaging I uderstand imaging trough an eyepiece, effectively haveing the scope not forming a real image at all. I don't think that is what you want to do here.

You likely want do do prime focus imaging with a camera that has the image sensor fairly deep recessed into its casing, like a DSLR.
In this case you can use either move the prime focal plane with a barlow or a relay lens, but both methods have significant disadvantages and are rarely used therefore.
So there is only one way out as you have correctly identified: mechanically move the focuser towards the mirror or vice versa.

Michael

Posted 05/18/2009 06:57PM #2
Bob,

Do I understand your question correctly:

You have a Newt.
You want to mount a camera to it.
When you do, you move the focuser in, and as you are moving in it starts to come to focus, but before it gets sharp, you run out of travel.

If I have that situation right,you need to reduce the distance between your primary and the focal plane. May I suggest:

....RE-collimate such that your collimation bolts are out (or in, depending on your colliimation setup) as far as they can go and still collimate your mirror. Collimation bolts have as much as half an inch of leeway.

....use as short a connector as possible with the t-ring to mate to your camera. (Of course, these things tend to be very short already)

....replace your focuser with a lower profile focuser. (You may want to do this anyway, because the focuser for a typical newt may not have been designed to handle the more critical fine focusing and weight requirements of imaging.)

....Move the mirror forward. This is usually a lot easier than you might think. It could be as simple as drilling three holes further up the sonotube. Or, however your mirror cell is mounted, inserting some shims/blocks and longer bolts to push the mirror forward. Remember that this will almost surely change your balance point. THis may or may not be a big deal. And it may be inevitable if you are thinking about mounting a camera anyway.

After that, there are some things you can change optically (like the Barlow, and afocal imaging) but these things change the nature of your imaging---and I would not suggest they are good first solutions.

Alex


Posted 05/23/2009 02:39PM #3
Hi Bob,

I have a different solution.

I have some friends with both a 22" and a 25" Obsession. I introduced them to binoviewers. They also have a Canon 20Da DSLR. They could not reach focus in their scopes with the DSLR.

I have a Siebert 2" binoviewer and I bought a Siebert MultiMag OCA to go with it. I have used it in our clubs 25" DOB and I was sure I could focus in the Obsessions with it. I got to thinking about it and I began to wonder if the MultiMag could solve the focus problem for DSLR's.

The Multimag is a little better than a Barlow because it has lower magnification powers.

My friends setup their new 25" Obsession Tuesday night and I brought over my Canon XSi 12 megapixel camera. We took shots with their 20Da and with my Canon XSi. The live view in the XSi was easier to use than the FC mode in the 20Da.

The colmination was not perfect. This is a new scope and they are still working with it. Also the tracking was not perfect and this was not a guided image. The focus might have been off a little too.

The attached is a 20 second exposure of M13 taken at 800 ISO with the XSi.

WE were concerned about any vignetting but I do not see any. This image was taken at full resolution resized to 800 X 533. It is not cropped. I did use picaso to bring up the overall gain a little.

Don Dubrin

Attached Image:

DonDurbin's attachment for post 130466