Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Mewlon OTA Recommendations?

Started by SJJindra, 04/01/2009 12:46AM
Posted 04/01/2009 12:46AM | Edited 04/01/2009 02:26AM Opening Post
I love the planetary views through my FS-128, but at times would like to move up a level or two but still with the refractor like sharpness. I am currently looking into purchasing one of the Takahashi Mewlon OTAs. It would be intended to replace a nice Celestron 9.25" and compliment the FS-128 for planetary viewing and webcam imaging. I would also plan to use it for brighter deep sky viewing and imaging (with an SXV-H9) from my light poluted home in the Houston area. My visual mount is an ASGT and my imaging mount is an AP-600E.

I'm thinking the M210 may be the best fit. My concern is that the M180 may not improve the planetary views considerably over my FS-128 and the M250 may overwelm my mounts (and budget) for the intended purposes.

Please let me know your recommendations and the pros and cons you have observed for the Mewlon OTAs.

Thanks
Steven Jindra
Posted 04/01/2009 02:47AM #1
I have a Mewlon 180 and have compared it fairly extensively to 5.5" and 4" apochromats. My personal impression is that the Mewlon 180 is going to offer roughly equivalent performance on Jupiter to your FS-128. This is pretty much what one would expect from the usual rule-of-thumb for such things (equivalent aperture for low contrast features = primary aperture - secondary aperture). On the whole I find the rule of thumb is a pretty good guideline (assuming equivalently good optics).

The Mewlon 180 is my favorite portable planetary scope on account of its small size, mount-friendliness and resistance to dewing up. However, I personally would not consider it a step up from an FS-128 for planetary viewing (more a step sideways).

Bob
Posted 04/01/2009 01:24PM #2
Steve,

I have a Mewlon 210 which has yet to see first light due to the weather but two statements I can make with certainty are that (1) it is very portable with respect to its weight and (2) it is very portable (again) due to its volume.

With 8+ inches of aperture, I believe it is one alternative that one should seriously look into.

If you can wait slightly, please be patient and I hope to start posting lots of images (especially DSO's) taken through my Mewlon 210.

Anthony.
Posted 04/02/2009 01:23AM #3
I appreciate the replies from all. They give me some good things to consider on the M180, M210, and M250 OTAs. With the economic situation, it is more important than ever to make the right decision on such major purchases. An M250 (along with the FS-128) would optically set me for life, but it may be a little much for the ASGT for visual and it's long focal length would be hard to tame for any DS imaging with my AP-600E. To move up in a mount too, would put me into another order of magnitude on the budget. I will keep my eyes open and see if a really good deal on either pops up.
Thanks
Steven Jindra
Posted 04/02/2009 01:51PM | Edited 04/02/2009 01:52PM #4
Steven,
I have had an FS-128 and now have an FS-152. I find the 10 inch Mewlon to be a perfect complement to the refractor. I know your mount may not be up to weight of the larger scope, but stepping up to a larger GEM may be worth it for you in the long run. As one possible example, the Orion Atlas offered by Anacortes would provide excellent stability for both your refractor and the larger Mewlon.

I will echo many of Herb's comments on the M-250.

I have not used the smaller Mewlons, I can only tell you what I know about mine. Therefore my comments are through the myopic lens of an 10 inch Mewlon owner.

Killer optics - Razor sharp stars and planets.
Very high contrast images. This really helps bring out detail on deep sky objects.
Compact OTA. Overall it is easy to manage. The back has much of the weight, the front 3/4 of the OTA is very light weight.
The scope is practically dew proof. Where I live we get a lot of humidity in the summer. I have had it out on several foggy nights when everything except the inside of the Mewlon OTA and mirrors were dripping wet. The OTA acts as a very effective dew shield.
I can set my scope up on the mount at a medium height and sit comfortably in a small hunting chair to study objects for long periods of time.
I love the electric focuser. You do not need to touch the OTA, it is very smooth, and very precise. The benefit of the electric focuser can not be over stated. No mirror shift. Zero.
The collimation stays put.
It is a work of art.
Small central obstruction.
Again: killer optics

In the end it comes down to what you can see. The combination of the large mirror, exquisite construction, razor sharp optics, high contrast, and comfortable viewing position make observing a unique pleasure. The aperture difference between your refractor and the M250 would be a huge jump. This is why I think it is worth considering. To give you an idea, I call my Mewlon, the "Cluster Buster".

One more story. The last time Mars was close I was observing the planet with my Mewlon when a friend suggested we try some higher power EPs. I kept working through my case until I got to my 5mm Takahashi LE. At 600x we were awestruck while looking at the planet's volcano. No other scope out that night even came close to the Takahashi's performance.

Best of luck with your research and decision.
Paul
Posted 04/03/2009 05:30PM | Edited 04/03/2009 06:05PM #5
Scott
My AP-600E is in a small observatory in my back yard, and on good nights I use this setup to begin imaging DSOs (usually Nebula through an Ha filter due to light pollution), then use my ASGT mount with another OTA for visual or webcam imaging. I have no doubt that the M250 would work fine for visual and imaging of planets and the brightest DSOs on my 600E mount, but would be too much focal length (2200mm+ with FR) for the 3 to 20 minute images required for most other DSOs. I'm afraid the M250 would also be a little too much for comfortable high powered viewing on my ASGT mount as well.

I believe an M210 is a better match, cost-wise at this time for my budget and weight-wise for the ASGT for higher powered visual and planetary webcam imaging, while my FS-128 is used for taking DSO images on the 600E. Plus, since I have to carry my visual set out into the yard, I like the portability of the size and weight combination of these two.

This is not to say that the positive comments about the M250 are ignored. In the future, when my budget allows and I'm ready to move up to a heavier duty, precision mount, the M250 will definitely be given additional consideration.

But for now, I just accepted a nice offer on a used M210 from a respected Astromarter. If all goes well on the purchase and delivery, I'll let you know the results when I've had time to use it for it's intended purpose for a while.

Scott - thanks to you and all the other contributors to this thread.

Sincerely
Steven Jindra
Posted 08/10/2009 05:54PM | Edited 08/10/2009 05:55PM #6
Just to follow up, I had ordered an M210 from a gentleman internationally, but the deal fell through. I now have a previously owned Mewlon 180 coming this week. This will allow me to leave the FS-128 set up more for imaging and use the M180 primarily for visual use.

I just made a deal for a Nexstar 8SE mount (a single arm mount with a Vixen dovetail), without the OTA, to install the M180 OTA on. This should allow for easy setup with an alt-az go-to mount. I'm hoping this will work out well, as I like the way an alt-az mount usually places the eyepiece very conveniently for viewing, while in a comfortably (sitting) position. The main thing will be that there are no noticable vibrations induced by the mount's tracking while viewing at higher power (250X).

I'll report back when I get everything together and tested.
Thanks
Steven Jindra