Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Survey - Taking this from another angle

Started by Ron777, 07/23/2004 03:43PM
Posted 07/23/2004 03:43PM Opening Post
OK, I thought I'd try one last line of questions here. Included is a pic that is close to my best view of Jupiter with my 10 inch dob on our best night of seeing. The best view was at about 272X even though I could observe at over 500. It was probably a teeny bit more sharp then this, I could see a bit more of the tendrils hanging off the bands than this shows. But it's close.

Here is the question: What is the smallest scope you honestly could see Jupiter this well in?

Attached Image:

Ron777's attachment for post 17593
Posted 07/23/2004 04:00PM #1
Given exceptionally good seeing conditions, I'd think you could see Jupiter that well in a 4.5" reflector.
Posted 07/23/2004 04:15PM #2
Hi Ron
Please take this with a grain of salt, but based on the pic, I can say I have seen views like it from here in metro Atlanta, heavy light polution, and average seeing about Pickering 4 (poor) or 5 (fair) in a TV85. On nights of better seeing at about pickering 7 the views were much better than the pic but smaller. I have a Hardin DSH8" and on the average nights around here the views look about like the pic or a bit better but on better nights the view was much much better. It's hard to say without more info about the scope and conditions but my novice opinion is that you should be getting better than that with a 10". It could be collimation or your viewing location could be better. Others here should be able to offer other opinions.
Just my $.02
Buck
Posted 07/23/2004 04:36PM #3
hi,

i've seen better then that in my 6" Mak-Newt at 300x


clear skies,

Larry Citro
Posted 07/23/2004 04:47PM #4
I have been very surprised when using my 4" refractor on planets during rare nights of superb seeing. The details available at ~200x on Jupiter and once at ~275x on Saturn demonstrated to me that the limiting factor was seeing and the equipment could really go beyond what I normally experience.

I have seen much greater detail (albeit, a much smaller image) on jupiter a few times through my 4" refractor.

Given those ideal conditions, which do occur, I would say this detail should be available in perhaps an 80mm refractor. It's been some years since I used an 80mm refractor, but as I recall, I was able to get images with more detail than illustrated in your photo on a few occasions.

Gary Weber
Posted 07/23/2004 05:21PM #5
I can see it better than that with my NS8GPS 8" SCT. I may have better viewing conditions here though.
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 07/23/2004 05:27PM | Edited 07/23/2004 05:28PM #6
I simpathize with you Ron. I think there are still problems with your simulated image, in my opinion:

1) the image scale is still way too large.

2) the detail all looked blurry, not a single sharp features (even when reduced 50%)

3) the contrast in the picture looked very bad.

Now, I think we both have Discovery scope, right? Mine is the 8" f/6 Discovery PDHQ (yours is a 10"). Here's what Jupiter (which was already passed opposition) looked to me with my 8" Discovery.
http://www.cloudynights.com/observe/ronbee/Jupiter/Jupiter-050904.html
http://www.cloudynights.com/observe/ronbee/Jupiter/Jupiter-050804-PDHQ.html

Even on nights of average seeing, there was always moments of steadiness and sharp, crisp view. On better nights, many of the features were so razor sharp, very high contrast!

Please grant me a thousand pardons for saying this. But it could be there's something wrong with your Discovery (you may wish to call Bill) or it's simply a matter of your area of torridly poor seeing :-(. Also try lower magnification; just because you've got a 10-incher doesn't mean 272x is usable with Jupiter on a particular night. The Discovery PDHQ Dob is truly a wonderful planetary scope to me ;-)!

Best wishes,
Ron B[ee]
Posted 07/23/2004 06:03PM #7
Ron,

I've posted these before, but I think they are worth adding to the thread:



11" Starmaster, 305x. Represents what I saw (i.e. this is not my image).

Here are 3 more representations under different seeing conditions:

Good:



Avg (for me):



Bad (I get a lot of this):



I like the first image as a representation of what I saw, but the level of detail can vary based on the resolution of your monitor. I can say that your image looks like what I might see on a 5 of 10 seeing night. Not great, but fun to look at.

Clear skies,

Tom
Posted 07/24/2004 12:06AM #8
With good collimation and good seeing I had better views with my C5+

Just my 2cents

Frank
Posted 07/24/2004 12:38AM #9
70mm Pronto or 89mm Questar.

Joe Bergeron

Moderator, Astro-Physics Forum