Eyepiece Confessional

Started by Jud, 05/06/2007 03:03AM
Posted 05/06/2007 03:03AM Opening Post
Considering the hiatus between when I started observing in the 50s with my RV6 and my return to the hobby after a dry period of over 40 years, you may as well call me a newbee who started a little over 2 years ago. In that short time I have owned at least 27 EPs; 15 of which I still have and consider at least keepers (no Naglers yet). For the other 12, they were so bad that I could not bring myself to sell them except for 2 which were requested on Astromart.

Unfortunately I first tried them out in an F/6 8" dob, but am now using a faster F/5 12" dob. Cheap widfield EPs in a fast dob (to quote a fellow astromarter) don't play well together. Most didn't improve much when barlowed.

Unfortunately it took me way to long to learn and heed the advice of others. Price was an initial bane, and for some people I know, still a problem. Also, the opportunity to use other astronomers EPs and scopes was insufficient to provide me with adequate experience to make reasonable decisions. How about a few war stories.

Would you sage owners of Naglers, Pentax, etc., care to share your first trials with lesser mortal EPs so that others may learn from your misfortunes. Although, two years ago I probably would not have listened anyway.

I Yam What I Yam!
Posted 05/06/2007 03:55AM #1
I started the hobby in 1960 and have been involved since. My first scope, a 4" reflector, lasted me about 10 years and I used two Kellner eyepieces and a barlow. Later I added a Ramsden to that. That was it. My first major upgrade was when I ground an 8" mirror about 35 years ago and purchased 3 plossls. At that time, owning simple plossls was like owning a box full of Naglers. I want to laugh today when I hear people refer to plossls as inferior or like "looking down a straw", etc. I remember when plossls were very cool.

Since, I have had the pleasure of owning lots of eyepieces, but have "matured" my belief that you only need about 3-5 eyepieces per scope. Lowest useful power, low power, medium power, high power and highest useful power. My other advice is to buy quality eps, such as any of the Televues or Pentax. Try all you can and put comfort ahead of tiny differences in constrast, lateral color, etc. Fewer, high quality eyepieces are way better than a box full of junk at every imaginable focal length.

But, "junk" is a thousand times better than nothing and most of today's "junk" is wonderful compared to the Kellners and Ramsdens I used to own.

Randy Roy
Posted 05/06/2007 01:02PM | Edited 05/06/2007 01:04PM #2
Judson
I pretty much echo your story. I was always interested in the stars and heavens. As a youngster back in the late 50's and early 60's I passed the time waiting for the school bus by watching the stars. Marveled at them while laying in the bush in Vietnam. When Halley's Comet came around I bummed a scope and went camping with my wife in N. GA and found it, and the following weekend we backpacked into a remote mountain top and found it in some small 10x25mm binoculars. A Boy Scout Troop came up and were not far away so I showed them how to find it and left the bino's for them to explore, and went to bed. We heard ooohs and aaaws and a few WOW's till late. For the next few years I've pulled out larger binos on published celestial events. But then about 5 years ago my wife asked me if I wanted a scope for Xmas so I started to read these and the other forums and with some good advise I picked up a TV85/Gibraltar off Amart and a TV8-24 to get started. IIRC Randy was a regular on a few forums then also. Where you and I differ is I didn't know squat about eyepieces and listened to many different folks and after a while it seemed most folks liked the TV line with very few dissenters. At that point I purchased a few Panoptics and was quite happy until temptation got the best of me and picked up the 13T6 Nagler. Very slippery and costly slope it was. I wheeled and dealed, and squeezed the rat hole money till the poke was empty and now have the NP101 SM11"f5.4 and a case of Naglers. So to date the thirst has been quenched. I still consider myself a biginner. I view strickly for my own enjoyment and don't have to view at every opportunity, and sometimes I just sit outside at night with some small bino's and look around and howl at the moon.
Just my $.002
Buck
Posted 05/06/2007 04:15PM #3
Judson Mitchell said:
Cheap widfield EPs in a fast dob (to quote a fellow astromarter) don't play well together.

Hi Judson,

Don't think I made it up, but that's the first time I've been quoted on AM. grin

From my first time under a dark sky in the UP of Michigan in the late 60's along with being a 10 year old space junkie at that time I was hooked.

Binoculars and the naked eye were all I had until taking Astronomy 101 my sophomore year at college. It met once a week in the evening and if it was clear afterward the professor would set up a small refractor. Got my first look at Saturn and Jupiter through a telescope and was still hooked, but poor.

Finally bought an 8" LX200 in 2001. I used plossel EPs until I winced and bought a 19mm Panoptic. So this was what everyone was talking about, wide fields and sharp images compared to other less expensive wide field EPs. I also tried University Optics MK40mm and a 32mm Konig. Great at f10, but when I bought my first dob they weren't good at the edge. My second premium EP was the 24 Panoptic-WOW!

I've since moved on to Naglers for the wider fields, but had a hiccup here too. Started with the new T6s' but they didn't have enough eye relief for my tastes and eyelashes.

I now have what I consider my "final" set of EPs. If I never buy another I would be happy with these for a long time.

26T6 - traded the 24Pan + $ to a guy needing another for a binoviewer
17T4 - bought new on sale a couple of years ago
12T4 - bought used here after I sold a 13mm T6
8mm Vixen super wide - got for a steal at a swap meet.
Nagler 3-6 zoom - bought new-OUCH! :S GREAT EP!

I have a 22mm Vixen SW - bought here used, too, and while it's a great EP the FOV is about the same as the 17T4, so I don't use it as much, but I'm also reluctant to sell it. :S

Some nights I am happy with just the 26 and 17, if conditions are better I go for the higher powers.

My 2 cents. smile
Posted 05/06/2007 06:19PM | Edited 05/06/2007 06:27PM #4
I started with I believe a 600 refractor back in 1965. Couldn't "find" a thing with it so used mostly for terrestrial. Then moved up to a 4.5" Reflector which was wonderful. Again, not sure who's brand. After that got some astro fever and ground my own mirror to make a scope plus got an 8" mirror from someplace and me and my dad build a Newtonian around that and used an Edmunds equatorial to hold it. We built the tube out of stainless steel! I recall all the drill bits we went thru poking the various holes in that tough metal. It was a tank for sure, but it sure performed and I'd routinely go 100x per inch with that thing on the Moon. Was out looking at the Apollo landing sites each time they landed or took off from those adventures. Up to this time I had the typical 1.25" eyepieces from Edmunds or Celestron. Then this new thing came out on the market called a Nagler or something so I ventured into my 1st premium EP and spent all my money on 2 eyepieces, a 4.8mm Nagler and a 24mm Wide Field. These things were like a quantum leap over everything else (and I still have them).

After the 8" home made Newt, I downsized back to my 4.25" Newt and that served me forever. Then I went to college and dropped the hobby. Finally, when I graduated and began to earn some money I got back into it and got myself a present of a C-8 Delux. That was one great scope and I used my 2 premium EPs in it, but also had the Celestron Orthos and Erfles which also worked quite well. In transit as I moved from the East coast to Chicago, the C-8 was stolen by the moving company and in the light polluted Chicagoland area I just picked up a Meade 2045 102mm SCT to hold me over. I kept and used that for 10 years before I finally (now back on the East coast) picked up my Orion XT10i and it has been the greatest thing since apple pie. I think a 10" is a great compromise between size and performance. It's "big" but still a very "personal" instrument. With the 10" and it's great performance I have gone EP crazy and have run thru just about everything short of Zeiss Orthos and Meades. So aside from those just about everything else has been in my stall that was worth being in there.

So after all this time, where has the EP journey taken me? To a very mixed spot, not of the one line or perfect EP that everyone is searching for, mut of overlapping EPs since no one EP is strong in everything that I may end up needing while observing. So on the high power end I at times need wide fields so I can get more context. For this, the T6s are used and their primary usage is for Lunar and Globs since they excel there (note the Hyperions or XWs would have done as well or even better in the case of the XWs, but a personal preference of mine is for high power EPs to be a smallish form factor, so this gave the T6s the edge as wide-fields). For sharpest on-axis work for planets and doubles and DSO, I've settled on Tak LEs as being the best in my tests for these objects. Sure the SMC Orthos are a tad better, but the Taks do almost as good plus have the larger afov and the nice 10mm eye relief so better than typical orthos or plossls. But so far, except for the SMC Orthos, nothing (yes nothing!) has been sharper on-axis, nor as contrasty.

On the low power end the search for something I really like in a fast Dob, with it's fast optics issues off-axis, has been really hard - especially since I do not like adding a Parracor into the mix since I have tried it and I don't like the extra magnification and I can detect the light loss from the extra glass quite easily. Add to my problem that I really don't enjoy 2" EPs all too much because I don't like fussing with switching between 1.25" format and 2" and the search is even more difficult. So again, I've had a host of Plossls and Erfles in the longer focal lengths and nothing really stellar IMO. The best view to date has been thru the Panoptics and older TV Wide Fields when I get longer than 15mm. But another personal preference for me has been the discovery that I don't like rectilinear distortion in my low power EPs since I have gotten used to things being orthogonally correct with the Erfles and Plossls I have been using over the years. So when I pop my TV Wide Field for instance in the focuser and look at a familiar subject, the star positions being somewhat off from true just looks "wrong" to me. Same with Panoptics and Naglers in the longer FLs. So my search has not yielded much luck until the 40mm Paragon came along. Now that is nice - every star in the place it should be across the field. But what to do about the 15-25mm range since no Paragon's yet? Well, since I can't wait, I went for the 14mm and 21mm Denks. Beautiful looking, small form factor, big eye lens, good edge correction in the fast dob, and almost zero rectilinear issues! Finally I'm happy smile

So there you have it, after Celstron Orthos-Erfles and Meade Plossls-MAs and RKEs, and UO Erfles-Orthos-Konigs and Sieberts Ultras-StarSplitters-Observatories and TeleVue Plossls-Panoptics-Naglers-Radians and Pentax XW-SMC Orthos-XFs and BO/TMB Planteries-WAs-Monocentrics and Orion/Baader Stratus-Hyperions and Takahashi Les what I have ended up with are:
**Hi Power Resolution - Tak LEs
**Hi Power Context - Nagler T6
**Mid Power - Pentax XF
**Lo Power - Denks and Paragon

So now that I've found my stall am I finished? Nope sad Because I've discovered that if I can get my scopes focal ratio at f/15 or above, then the Pentax XFs and Denks smoke all the high power EPs when the hi power EPs are in the scope at f/5!! I mean smoke them! So if I throw a good 3x Barlow under the XFs or Denks, then the T6s, LEs, and even the SMC Orthos aren't as sharp. So I guess that brings us back to the olden days of scopes for us high power junkies - focal ratio RULES!

It's just never ending - guess that's why it's so much fun smile
Posted 05/06/2007 06:54PM | Edited 05/06/2007 06:54PM #5
I have had everything from Meade MA to No Name Plossls and much in between. In the last 4 years here I have sold atleast 100 EPs of all types. I have had three sets of Orthos and TV Wide Fields-Plossls, Meade SWA-UWA and many Siebert EPs too. Many worked well with my SCT, but not with the faster DOBs.
Today I have narrowed my collection down to EPs with good eye relief and fairly wide fields from 60-82° for the most part, with a few exceptions.
For me, comfort has become a big issue that is as important as FOV. The other important factor is usability in any scope, refractor to reflector, fast to slow. I find it easier to have a set that works well with anything I own, rather than having a set for each type, like I had for a while.
The cost factor is always an issue, no matter who you are I suppose. But, if you get good quality EPs, then your turn over is very little and this saves money in the end.
I like Naglers, Panoptics, Pentax, Zeiss, Meade UWAs and some of the newer planetary and specialty EPs that have come onto the market.
My collection is not all TV that is for sure, but I have a fair share of the TV in it. I try EPs when I get the chance and then if I find something that I really like, I look for a deal on it. I try not to be too impatient and wait for a good one. Sometimes it happens right away and sometimes it takes a year. But if it is really good, then I am willing to wait.
I think that one can get by with 3-5 EPs quite well. When you exceed this number it is the specialty EPs that add to the number. If you like planetary and Double Stars, then you need some EPs designed for that use. You don't have to have them, but it does make it nice.
Astromart has provided me with a source for my EPs that is hard to beat. I normally buy used anymore, though I have purchased a number of new ones too. But when it comes to the high dollar ones, I try to find that excellent used example at a great price and so far have been very lucky.
I did not see the difference between high quality optics and EPs at first, perhaps because I was too busy looking at the objects and not the details? But now it is quite obvious when I use a fine ocular vs. a lessor version of the focal length.
Really, life is short and enjoyment is a big part of living, so go for the gusto and enjoy your hobby. Buy the best that you can and then be satisfied with it. That is the key to this hobby I think. 8)

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 05/06/2007 10:15PM #6
As a non-sage owner of no Naglers nor Pentax's it has been my experience that premium ep's really do work well. Membership in astro clubs give even us tight wads the opportunity to see the difference well correct for fast focal ratio's, coma correction, and superior glass and coatings on those multi elements can actually do. And can't do.

I've never met a member of the NGC that could _only_ be seen in the most expensive ep of a given focal length. But well coated and decent field correction regardless of the size of that field, beats budget wide field every time.


Some valuble work arounds for lack of premium glass in the focuser are:

Fix the movements on the dang alt-az mount for smoother navigation.

Detailed diagrams of where one is looking.

Powered finder rather than unit finder.
Posted 05/07/2007 05:12AM | Edited 05/07/2007 06:28PM #7
First, as you get older, a binoviewer will become more and more important to help your degrading eyesight. Consider that fact. If you are past 50, you will probably never be without a binoviewer if you ever try one of the really good ones: Baader, Siebert, Denkmeier, Tele Vue, Lumicon. If you use high power, floaters are a pain at planetary mags, and you can knock them down 75% or so with a binoviewer. I suggest getting a scope with a focuser that negates the need for an OCA if you want the absolute best resolution. Get a binoviewer that's hung together well, not the generic Chinese one that sells cheaply. The Baader Maxbright or Siebert BN22 are your lowest cost quality binoviewers.

Some of my best EP's in my f/4 SNT are the Siebert Star Splitters which will set you back about $90. Anything from 7.9mm on down (5-element) works great in fast scopes. The 8.9mm and 9.9mm (triplets) are for slow scopes, but are knockout performers in slow Mak-Cass scopes. The Star Splitters have a very similar eye relief and eye lens diameter to the Celestron 12.5mm Ultima, and are perfect for extending down from there for planetary use. Their ultra light weight makes them perfect for binoviewers.

If you want 2" EP's, then the Hyperions are excellent and affordable.

The Siebert Power Mag Wheel allows me to even use Kellners to good effect in my f/4 SNT. That may be the cheapest route if you have a big EP collection. Not having to change EP's is a big plus when observing consecutive objects, and checking for most useful mag. It will hold a 2" EP, but fits into a 1.25" focuser.

I like 1.25" EP's for binov use, but I would suggest getting 2" Barrelled EP's for monoviewing use as they are far more comfortable for that, and the Hyperions are so affordable and so adaptable to camera use that it's silly not to have a few, which I soon plan on getting. Compare a cheap $50 2" 26mm E-Lux Kellner to a high quality 1.25" 25mm Plossl, and you will soon see how superior the bigger Kellner is for deep sky use, if your scope is f/10 or slower. You can really roll your eye around without blackouts, which many of the ultra wideangles EP's are very poor at.

Dobs make EP selection harder, as excellent wideangle EP's like the old Axioms work best at f/7 and slower. My 2" Axioms and 2" Siebert Observatory set the standard for comfort. The major fault of the 2" Observatory series is it's limited focal length range. It's an excellent Dob EP for maxing out your FOV. Less distortion than a Panoptic, and much lighter and cheaper.

Get a Baader Click-Lock adapter for your 1.25" EP's and with a 2" T-2 nosepiece it doubles as an adapter for your 2" focuser with nearly 2" of backfocus added. In other words, you go from camera to visual without needing an extension tube. It's the best support for a binoviewer as it is self centering. Standard adapters with a single setscrew will have wobble that lets the binov view separate from the finder view as you slew around the sky. The Click-Lock uses 3-point centering with considerable length to the contact points that span over safety undercuts in EP Barrels. It does NOT have fallout protection, but depends on strong clamping action. If EP or diagonal is pointing down, it will fall out if loosening of clamp ring occurs. I do not recommend it for diagonal mounting, as Baader makes a much better quick-dosconnect ring system for that.

All Dob type focusers set for 35mm camera use will need an extension tube to go visual as there is a 55mm front flange to film plane distance on all 35mm cameras. The Click-Lock does two things with one accessory, and you can add extension tubes between it and the nosepeice to get any backfocus extension you need.
Posted 05/07/2007 03:40PM #8
Some really great insights here on WHY some of you have selected your ep collections! I think, for the time being, I have settled on the scopes I'll be using--a 14" truss dob, an 8" solid tube dob, and a short tube 80 refractor. I agree with the comment that I'd rather have one good set of eypieces than a whole lot of inferior ones, as well as with the remark that I'd rather have a set of ep's that would with all my scopes than a set for every scope. For that reason I have wittled down my collection considerably. Comfort IS important to me (why not?) so for the most part I have gotten rid of my plossls and orthos that have insufficient eye relief, I ony keep three longer focal length pairs of Antares Elites for my bv's, where they work quite well. I might start the evenings observing with a low power finder ep, something like the 35 Panoptic. Jumping in mag from the low end of the pool, I generally like to double the power, so I might choose something like a 17 Nagler next. After that I like the comfortable eyerelief and sharp views of the Pentax line, so I may take out a 10.5 XL, or the lovely 7 XW. I tossed in a lightweight, compact 19 Pan for my wide-field refractor, and I've got pretty much what I need!
Larry
Posted 05/07/2007 04:47PM #9
LOTS of great advice here. I don't have much to add. I played EP roulette for a couple years, too, and eventually ended up with mostly Naglers with a few others. I use the Naglers the most by far, mainly because the T6 are parfocal and "play well" with a fast dob.

One thing I found out, though. Usually when I find a good deal and buy an EP used, I can usually sell it for the same price I paid. I might have to pay for shipping, but $5 or $10 to "rent" an EP seems like a pretty good deal. And to justify it in my mind, it's an even better deal for $200+ Naglers than for $50 EPs!

Kevin