The focal length of my scope is 2300mm, with a 5X powermate it would be 11,500mm. Would Jupiter or Saturn fit on the Toucam chip at this FL? If so, would keeping it on the chip for the AVI capture be too tedious using an alt/az drive like the Servocat. I think some of you are imaging at some pretty high FL's on Dobs so I'd like to hear what you think before I plunk down the bucks for a 5X powermate as it would be only used for webcam imaging, thanks in advance.
max FL for Toucam chip
Started by vbert, 03/17/2004 05:00PM
Posted 03/17/2004 05:00PM
Opening Post
Posted 03/17/2004 06:44PM
#1
A 5x powermate is too much for fl = 2300mm. The mag is actually closer to 7x and the light is so collimated that every minscule piece of dirt on the ccd window shows up as a donut. The 2.5X does the job perfectly. There is graph somewhere on the web that shows the magnification for the 2.5X and the 5X that illustrates this but I can't find it now
Posted 03/17/2004 06:51PM
#2
Vincent -
I think it will be too much magnification. They might just fit but the seeing will only rarely allow you to get any benefit from this pixel scale. I use a tracking mount but I would have to think it would be very difficult to keep an image on the chip with your set-up. There are many other barlows to choose from. An interesting choice is the Baader FFC unit which is variable from about 3X to 8X with the use of extensions - but this is a very costly unit.
Others may have different suggestions -
good luck -
Alan
I think it will be too much magnification. They might just fit but the seeing will only rarely allow you to get any benefit from this pixel scale. I use a tracking mount but I would have to think it would be very difficult to keep an image on the chip with your set-up. There are many other barlows to choose from. An interesting choice is the Baader FFC unit which is variable from about 3X to 8X with the use of extensions - but this is a very costly unit.
Others may have different suggestions -
good luck -
Alan
Alan Friedman
http://www.avertedimagination.com
Posted 03/17/2004 07:02PM
#3
I have a 5x Powermate and have used it twice for imaging with my C8. You can see one image here:
http://glory.gc.maricopa.edu/~pmaxson/Mars/October/Mars1023txt.jpg
There is a huge difference in quality of image from the 3x televue and 5x powermate. I love the powermate for visual use, but probably will never use it for imaging. Jupiter darn near filled the field of view on the C8.
The folks who use the 5x on dobs are using it with typically F/4 - F/4.5 systems and it gets them to about F/25 or F/30, which seems to be the sweet spot on focal ratio for webcam imaging.
Paul Maxson
http://glory.gc.maricopa.edu/~pmaxson/Mars/October/Mars1023txt.jpg
There is a huge difference in quality of image from the 3x televue and 5x powermate. I love the powermate for visual use, but probably will never use it for imaging. Jupiter darn near filled the field of view on the C8.
The folks who use the 5x on dobs are using it with typically F/4 - F/4.5 systems and it gets them to about F/25 or F/30, which seems to be the sweet spot on focal ratio for webcam imaging.
Paul Maxson
Paul Maxson
Moderator - CCD Imaging and Processing/Solar System
Celestron C14, Mewlon 250, Orion EON120, ASI120MM, Flea3.
http://www.sunspot51.com
Posted 03/17/2004 09:24PM
#4
Vincent,
I image with my 18" F/4.3 dob using a 5X's powermate. This gives me close to 10,000 mm fl or about F/22-25 with back focus of chip. I imagine with your setup 5X's would be too much as with my fl Jupiter is a tight squeeze (I attached a raw uncroppped frame to give you an idea) maybe just go with a 3X's for nights of really good seeing and stick with a 2 or 2.5X's the other nights. JMHO ;>)
cheers
Mike Wirths
I image with my 18" F/4.3 dob using a 5X's powermate. This gives me close to 10,000 mm fl or about F/22-25 with back focus of chip. I imagine with your setup 5X's would be too much as with my fl Jupiter is a tight squeeze (I attached a raw uncroppped frame to give you an idea) maybe just go with a 3X's for nights of really good seeing and stick with a 2 or 2.5X's the other nights. JMHO ;>)
cheers
Mike Wirths
Attached Image:
Funding Member