New 16 bit Atik cameras!!

Started by Mike Wirths, 06/21/2005 06:52PM
Posted 06/21/2005 06:52PM Opening Post
Hi all,

Just noticed that the new 16 bit cameras have been announced at Atik intruments.
http://www.atik-instruments.com
The one model ATK-16 has a ccd array 752x582 8.6x8.3 micron pixels. Its based on the Sony ICX-429ALL ExView CCD. The lowest shutter speed though is 1/1000th! So maybe too fast for lunar/planetary? Any of the techies out there have an opinion as to the usefulness of this new camera to us?

--Mike Wirths
Posted 06/21/2005 07:13PM #1
Hi Mike,

this should be a ready to go Artemis camera (developed by QCUIAG members) : http://www.artemisccd.co.uk/the_cameras.htm
I suppose it features only a USB1.X interface so that possible frame rates without lossy compression aren't what we want for planetary imaging.

Best regards & Clear skies,
Oliver

http://www.astro-imaging.de/astro
Posted 06/21/2005 10:07PM #2
Mike Wirths said:

Hi all,

Just noticed that the new 16 bit cameras have been announced at Atik intruments.
http://www.atik-instruments.com
The one model ATK-16 has a ccd array 752x582 8.6x8.3 micron pixels. Its based on the Sony ICX-429ALL ExView CCD. The lowest shutter speed though is 1/1000th! So maybe too fast for lunar/planetary? Any of the techies out there have an opinion as to the usefulness of this new camera to us?

--Mike Wirths

Mike - I think they mean that the *fastest* shutter speed is 1/1000 second. They list the maximum shutter as "unlimited" which I guess means something like 1000 seconds or more (just a guess).

Two things will determine whether this camera is useful for planetary work, and these are the two things where most camera makers fall down:

- flexible exposure & framerate selection, with the shutter disabled. i.e. exposures selectable from 10ms up to 80ms in small steps (say 1ms) with the framerate automaticlly adjusting to 1/exp (up to a maximum of, say, 40fps) and the camera integrating light for the full length of each frame.

- real usb2 or firewire data rates to support framerates up to 40fps at full frame resolution.

There are very few cameras on the market that meet these 2 criteria, but these criteria almost define a good planetary camera. That's one of the reasons the Lumenera LU075 is a nice camera, I think it meets these 2 items.

regards, Bird

http://www.acquerra.com.au/astro
Posted 06/23/2005 01:34AM #3
Rui hinted that his company was looking into a 16bit, USB2 planetary cam. He says cooled, high frame rate at 640x480.

Remains to be seen what comes of that.

Paul

Paul Maxson
Moderator - CCD Imaging and Processing/Solar System
Celestron C14, Mewlon 250, Orion EON120, ASI120MM, Flea3.
http://www.sunspot51.com
Posted 06/24/2005 10:55AM #4
Hi all,

I've been reading this thread, and I feel that I should add something to it.

Indeed, the new ATK-16 line is targeted to the DSO people. This is the vast majority of the market out there, and it was one of our priorities. This doesn't mean they can't do planets, but that wasn't the primary goal in our minds.

As Damian has mentioned, the venerable Toucam pro is still the best solution out there, with a unsurpassable "bang for buck" ratio. This is the solution that most people with limited resources choose (again, the vast majority).

Our approach here was the ATK-1HS, wich I still think it is a very good performer for the money. This camera suits most planetary imaging needs, even some advanced ones, because it supports long exposures. Take the example of Christophe Pellier, with his 1000nm IR images of Venus.

Of course, highly specialized observers prefer an uncompressed stream of data, as well as high frame rates, and that's where cameras such as the Lumenera go in. The only problem is price, since the ATK-1HS costs a little more than 1/3 of the Lumenera!

But be assured that we haven't forgotten your requests. As Paul Maxson said, there are some planets in our horizon... wink

In reply to Mike's coment on the quality of the images we have published on the Atik website, please note that these are single, unprocessed, test frames that have no darks applied. Most were done in really bad conditions, such as horrible seeing and bad transparency. The good stuff will start to come out shortly... smile

And Paolo, Atik is on the market for 1.5 years. How long is SBIG and Starlight? What would be really weird, was if you were seeing more Atiks than SBIG's... grin

Clear, steady skies to all.

Rui Tripa